Talk:Errors made by Expelled reviewers

From Conservapedia
Jump to: navigation, search


Shouldn't this just be made part of the Expelled article itself, or at least renamed to Errors made by reviewers of Expelled? As it stands now it's a broad title with information specific to the review(er)s of only one movie. Jinkas 11:38, 26 April 2008 (EDT)

Moved slightly. But I don't intend to add it to the article, since it is unrelated to the movie.
An article about attempts to discredit the movie might be interesting, but as a separate page. It might be linked from Premise Media or even added as a section to it, since they are the production company for Expelled.
We might do an article exploring the same theme as the movie, i.e., about the treatment of academics who write or teach about intelligent design. In that case, erroneous or deliberately false reviews of Expelled would be relevant, either to Premise Media or in Opposition to intelligent design. But false information about a movie is not related to the movie.
For example, a personal attack on Bush or Dawkins might make an interesting news story, or blog entry, but it would not go into an encyclopedia article. This web site is not a blog, is it? --Ed Poor Talk 12:03, 26 April 2008 (EDT)