Henry Morgenthau, Jr. - Revision history

RobSmith: /* Morgenthau plan */

2025-10-28T21:32:27Z

Morgenthau plan

RobSmith: /* Morgenthau plan */

2025-10-19T20:19:15Z

Morgenthau plan

RobSmith at 03:35, June 8, 2024

2024-06-08T03:35:16Z

RobSmith: /* Morgenthau plan */

2022-09-28T05:04:53Z

Morgenthau plan

RobSmith: /* Morgenthau plan */

2022-09-28T05:03:43Z

Morgenthau plan

RobSmith: /* Leaks */

2018-12-23T01:23:55Z

Leaks

RobSmith: /* Morgenthau plan */ clean up

2018-12-23T01:22:33Z

Morgenthau plan: clean up

Gentenaar: /* Morgenthau plan */

2017-02-11T15:23:41Z

Morgenthau plan

Gentenaar: /* Morgenthau plan */

2017-02-11T15:14:45Z

Morgenthau plan

Gentenaar: /* Morgenthau plan */

2017-02-11T15:14:08Z

Morgenthau plan

@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.   Hull said: "This was a plan of blind [[vengeance]] ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."
-The plan was [[leak]]ed to press and German Minister of Propaganda [[Joseph Goebbels]] reprinted it, telling the German people what the Allies had in store if Germany lost the war, increasing resistance after the [[Normandy Invasion]], including the use of the [[Hitler Youth]] and [[Volksturm]].  Gen. [[Dwight Eisenhower]] begged President Roosevelt to publicly renounce the plan because the fanatical resistance knowledge of the plan unleashed was getting more allied troops killed.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944, but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it didn't go into effect.  A modified version of the plan did however go into effect after the surrender, which caused mass starvation among the German population, primarily women, children and the elderly at that point due to high losses among men of fighting age, for the next two years.
+The plan was [[leak]]ed to press and German Minister of Propaganda [[Joseph Goebbels]] reprinted it, telling the German people what the Allies had in store if Germany lost the war, increasing resistance after the [[Normandy Invasion]], including the use of the [[Hitler Youth]] and [[Volkssturm]].  Gen. [[Dwight Eisenhower]] begged President Roosevelt to publicly renounce the plan because the fanatical resistance knowledge of the plan unleashed was getting more allied troops killed.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944, but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it didn't go into effect.  A modified version of the plan did however go into effect after the surrender, which caused mass starvation among the German population, primarily women, children and the elderly at that point due to high losses among men of fighting age, for the next two years.
 ===Leaks===

@@ Line 12: / Line 12: @@
 The Morgenthau plan, authored by Morgenthau's assistant [[Harry Dexter White]], called for ending the future war potential of Germany by shutting down its heavy industry in the Ruhr. The Ruhr,  "should be not only stripped of all existing industries but should be so weakened and controlled that it cannot in the foreseeable future become an industrial area ... All industrial plants and equipment not destroyed by military action shall either be completely dismantled or removed from the area or completely destroyed; all equipment shall be removed from the mines and the mines wrecked." The proposal looked forward to "converting Germany into a country principally agricultural and pastoral in character." In short, turning Germany into "a potato field", castrating males, and deporting the excess population that agricultures could not support to [[Libya]].
-The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.   Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."
+The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.   Hull said: "This was a plan of blind [[vengeance]] ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."
 The plan was [[leak]]ed to press and German Minister of Propaganda [[Joseph Goebbels]] reprinted it, telling the German people what the Allies had in store if Germany lost the war, increasing resistance after the [[Normandy Invasion]], including the use of the [[Hitler Youth]] and [[Volksturm]].  Gen. [[Dwight Eisenhower]] begged President Roosevelt to publicly renounce the plan because the fanatical resistance knowledge of the plan unleashed was getting more allied troops killed.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944, but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it didn't go into effect.  A modified version of the plan did however go into effect after the surrender, which caused mass starvation among the German population, primarily women, children and the elderly at that point due to high losses among men of fighting age, for the next two years.

@@ Line 1: / Line 1: @@
 [[Image:MorgenthauHenryJr2009-02-19.jpg‎|right|225px]]'''Henry Morgenthau, Jr.''' (May 11, 1891 – February 6, 1967) was appointed [[Secretary of the Treasury]] of the United States during the administration of [[Franklin D. Roosevelt]] from 1934-1945.
-Roosevelt biographer John Flynn described Morgenthau as "a slow, dull youth with no capacity for study. Up to the time he was given an important post by Roosevelt he had had no success in any kind of business. His father had set him up as a gentleman farmer on an estate next to Roosevelt's home at Hyde Park and endowed him with plenty of money. That is how he met Roosevelt and he remained for life the latter's humble and compliant servitor."
+Roosevelt biographer [[John T. Flynn]] described Morgenthau as "a slow, dull youth with no capacity for study. Up to the time he was given an important post by Roosevelt he had had no success in any kind of business. His father had set him up as a gentleman farmer on an estate next to Roosevelt's home at Hyde Park and endowed him with plenty of money. That is how he met Roosevelt and he remained for life the latter's humble and compliant servitor."
 ==New Deal==

@@ Line 14: / Line 14: @@
 The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.   Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."
-The plan was [[leak]]ed to press and German Minister of Propaganda [[Joseph Goebbels]] reprinted it, telling the German people what the Allies had in store if Germany lost the war, increasing resistance after the [[Normandy Invasion]], including the use of the [[Hitler Youth]] and [[Volksturm]].  Gen. [[Dwight Eisenhower]] begged President Roosevelt to publicly renounce the plan because the fanatical resistance knowledge of the plan unleashed was getting more allied troops killed.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944 but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it didn't go into effect.  A modified version of the plan did however go into effect after the surrender, which caused mass starvation among the German population, primarily women, children and the elderly at that point due to high losses among men of fighting age, for the next two years.
+The plan was [[leak]]ed to press and German Minister of Propaganda [[Joseph Goebbels]] reprinted it, telling the German people what the Allies had in store if Germany lost the war, increasing resistance after the [[Normandy Invasion]], including the use of the [[Hitler Youth]] and [[Volksturm]].  Gen. [[Dwight Eisenhower]] begged President Roosevelt to publicly renounce the plan because the fanatical resistance knowledge of the plan unleashed was getting more allied troops killed.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944, but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it didn't go into effect.  A modified version of the plan did however go into effect after the surrender, which caused mass starvation among the German population, primarily women, children and the elderly at that point due to high losses among men of fighting age, for the next two years.
 ===Leaks===

@@ Line 10: / Line 10: @@
 ==Morgenthau plan==
-The Morgenthau plan, authored by Morgenthau's assistant [[Harry Dexter White]], called for ending the future war potential of Germany by shutting down its heavy industry in the Ruhr. The Ruhr,  "should be not only stripped of all existing industries but should be so weakened and controlled that it cannot in the foreseeable future become an industrial area ... All industrial plants and equipment not destroyed by military action shall either be completely dismantled or removed from the area or completely destroyed; all equipment shall be removed from the mines and the mines wrecked." The proposal looked forward to "converting Germany into a country principally agricultural and pastoral in character."
+The Morgenthau plan, authored by Morgenthau's assistant [[Harry Dexter White]], called for ending the future war potential of Germany by shutting down its heavy industry in the Ruhr. The Ruhr,  "should be not only stripped of all existing industries but should be so weakened and controlled that it cannot in the foreseeable future become an industrial area ... All industrial plants and equipment not destroyed by military action shall either be completely dismantled or removed from the area or completely destroyed; all equipment shall be removed from the mines and the mines wrecked." The proposal looked forward to "converting Germany into a country principally agricultural and pastoral in character." In short, turning Germany into "a potato field", castrating males, and deporting the excess population that agricultures could not support to [[Libya]].
-The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.   Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."  When the Americans did invade Germany almost their first act was, and needed to be, to work the mines to fullest production to aid the European economy.  Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944 but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it never went into effect.
+The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base.  The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy.   Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe."
 ===Leaks===

@@ Line 15: / Line 15: @@
 ===Leaks===
-The contents of the Morgenthau Plan leaked <ref>FBI Silvermaster file, Statement by Harold Glasser to Agents Garland and Mossberg, [http://education-research.org/PDFs/Silvermaster116.pdf Vol. 116, pgs. 120 - 129] pdf, May 13, 1947. Glasser states: "during the conference, the press obtained details concerning the MORGANTHAU Plan before it was public. Shortly thereafter, while I was in Montreal, Canada, attending the Second Council Meeting of [[UNRRA]], EMELIO G. CALLAJO of the State Department was my roommate and I regard him as a very close friend.  During that time, I discussed the German Plan with him.  When MORGANTHAU and I had returned to the United States, MORGANTHAU called me to his office and accused me of the leakage to the press. I denied it at that time and of course I deny it now.  It is my opinion that through CALLAJO the State Department accused me of talking and being overheard by a newspaperman.  I know MORGANTHAU has never forgotten this and I believe that is the reason why I was passed over and [[FRANK COE]] was selected as the Director of the Division of Monetary Research when [[HARRY WHITE]] left the Treasury Department." (pgs. 128 - 129 pdf).</ref> to the papers and Roosevelt became alarmed at the violence of the reaction, a fine evidence of the fundamentally decent nature of the majority of Americans. Roosevelt tried to deny what he had done.<ref>''The Roosevelt Myth'', John T. Flynn, Fox and Wilkes, 1948, Book 3, Ch. 11, [http://www.rooseveltmyth.com/book/fdrmyth_Chapter_Eleven___How_Germany_s_F.htm ''How Germany's Fate Was Sealed'']</ref>
+The contents of the Morgenthau Plan leaked <ref>FBI Silvermaster file, Statement by Harold Glasser to Agents Garland and Mossberg, [http://education-research.org/PDFs/Silvermaster116.pdf Vol. 116, pgs. 120 - 129] pdf, May 13, 1947. Glasser states: "during the conference, the press obtained details concerning the MORGANTHAU Plan before it was public. Shortly thereafter, while I was in Montreal, Canada, attending the Second Council Meeting of [[UNRRA]], EMELIO G. CALLAJO of the State Department was my roommate and I regard him as a very close friend.  During that time, I discussed the German Plan with him.  When MORGANTHAU and I had returned to the United States, MORGANTHAU called me to his office and accused me of the leakage to the press. I denied it at that time and of course I deny it now.  It is my opinion that through CALLAJO the State Department accused me of talking and being overheard by a newspaperman.  I know MORGANTHAU has never forgotten this and I believe that is the reason why I was passed over and [[FRANK COE]] was selected as the Director of the Division of Monetary Research when [[HARRY WHITE]] left the Treasury Department." (pgs. 128 - 129 pdf).</ref> to the papers and Roosevelt became alarmed at the violence of the reaction, a fine evidence of the fundamentally decent nature of the majority of Americans. Roosevelt tried to deny ever signing an authorization to go forward with the plan.<ref>''The Roosevelt Myth'', John T. Flynn, Fox and Wilkes, 1948, Book 3, Ch. 11, [http://www.rooseveltmyth.com/book/fdrmyth_Chapter_Eleven___How_Germany_s_F.htm ''How Germany's Fate Was Sealed'']</ref>
 ==References==

← Older revision		Revision as of 01:22, December 23, 2018
Line 13:		Line 13:

	The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base. The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy. Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe." When the Americans did invade Germany almost their first act was, and needed to be, to work the mines to fullest production to aid the European economy. Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944 but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it never went into effect.		The Plan reflected wartime hatred of Nazi Germany, which had started and nearly won two great wars using its industrial base. The alternative was to reform the German people, and that idea won out. The Plan was strongly opposed by Secretary of State [[Cordell Hull]], by Secretary of War [[Henry Stimson]] and by the British and French because it would make Germans a perpetual enemy. Hull said: "This was a plan of blind vengeance ... It failed to see that in striking at Germany it was striking at all Europe." When the Americans did invade Germany almost their first act was, and needed to be, to work the mines to fullest production to aid the European economy. Roosevelt and Churchill seemed to agree with Morgenthau at the Quebec Conference in Sept. 1944 but in October Roosevelt vetoed the Morgenthau Plan and it never went into effect.
−
−	~~Nevertheless, it is used (to this day) by anti-American elements in Germany to attack America. {{citation needed}}~~

	===Leaks===		===Leaks===