Talk:Scalloped potatoes - Revision history

Ed Poor: Talk:Cheesy potatoes moved to Talk:Scalloped potatoes: American English

2008-12-14T23:21:54Z

Talk:Cheesy potatoes moved to Talk:Scalloped potatoes: American English

Dpbsmith at 18:31, March 10, 2007

2007-03-10T18:31:31Z

Dpbsmith: Retracting my comparison with Wikipedia. Valid, but not appropriate in a Conservapedia discussion.

2007-03-10T18:27:55Z

Retracting my comparison with Wikipedia. Valid, but not appropriate in a Conservapedia discussion.

Dpbsmith at 18:26, March 10, 2007

2007-03-10T18:26:14Z

Dpbsmith at 18:16, March 10, 2007

2007-03-10T18:16:33Z

Dpbsmith: My $0.02.

2007-03-10T18:16:05Z

My $0.02.

New page

What on earth is this all about --[[User:TimSvendsen|TimSvendsen]] 18:45, 9 March 2007 (EST)

This probably shouldn't exist. [[User:ATB|ATB]] 12:37, 10 March 2007 (EST)

I left a note on [[User talk:TimothyR|TimothyR]]'s talk page directing him here. I don't think anything should be done until he has a chance to respond.

My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)

TimSvendsen: a

2007-03-09T23:45:21Z

New page

What on earth is this all about --[[User:TimSvendsen|TimSvendsen]] 18:45, 9 March 2007 (EST)

@@ Line 5: / Line 5: @@
 I left a note on [[User talk:TimothyR|TimothyR]]'s talk page directing him here. I don't think anything should be done until he has a chance to respond.
-My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)
+My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. Perhaps he should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)
-[[User:MountainDew]] has deleted it. I don't think it should be undeleted, but I think this discussion should be continued and I think [[User talk:TimothyR|TimothyR]] should be heard from. [[User:Dpbsmith|Dpbsmith]] 13:27, 10 March 2007 (EST)
+[[User:MountainDew]] has deleted it. I don't think it needs to be undeleted, but I think this discussion should be continued and I think [[User talk:TimothyR|TimothyR]] should be heard from. [[User:Dpbsmith|Dpbsmith]] 13:27, 10 March 2007 (EST)

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:27, March 10, 2007
Line 7:		Line 7:
	My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)		My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)

−	[[User:MountainDew]] has deleted it. I don't think it should be undeleted, but I think this discussion should be continued and I think [[User talk:TimothyR\|TimothyR]] should be heard from. At <small><font color=A0A0A0>Wikipedia</font></small> this would not have been considered a valid "speedy deletion" (deleted by a sysop without discussion). It might have been a streamlined "proposed deletion" (listed for a few days and deleted if nobody complains) or might well have been a full-fledged AFD discussion, which would have turned on the point that Wikipedia has, for several years, not allowed articles that are simply cooking recipes, and the issue is whether "Cheesy potatoes" are of importance as part of the culture of the United States (as "Pecan pie" and "Cheesesteak" are). [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:26, 10 March 2007 (EST)	+	[[User:MountainDew]] has deleted it. I don't think it should be undeleted, but I think this discussion should be continued and I think [[User talk:TimothyR\|TimothyR]] should be heard from. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:27, 10 March 2007 (EST)

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:26, March 10, 2007
Line 6:		Line 6:

	My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)		My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)
		+
		+	[[User:MountainDew]] has deleted it. I don't think it should be undeleted, but I think this discussion should be continued and I think [[User talk:TimothyR\|TimothyR]] should be heard from. At <small><font color=A0A0A0>Wikipedia</font></small> this would not have been considered a valid "speedy deletion" (deleted by a sysop without discussion). It might have been a streamlined "proposed deletion" (listed for a few days and deleted if nobody complains) or might well have been a full-fledged AFD discussion, which would have turned on the point that Wikipedia has, for several years, not allowed articles that are simply cooking recipes, and the issue is whether "Cheesy potatoes" are of importance as part of the culture of the United States (as "Pecan pie" and "Cheesesteak" are). [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:26, 10 March 2007 (EST)

← Older revision		Revision as of 18:16, March 10, 2007
Line 5:		Line 5:
	I left a note on [[User talk:TimothyR\|TimothyR]]'s talk page directing him here. I don't think anything should be done until he has a chance to respond.		I left a note on [[User talk:TimothyR\|TimothyR]]'s talk page directing him here. I don't think anything should be done until he has a chance to respond.

−	My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)	+	My opinion is: if he is '''not''' one of the homeschooled students working on Conservapedia, an AFD on the article should be opened and discussed with the probable result being deletion. If he '''is''' one of the homeschoolers, in deference to him the article should be kept, but he should be asked to give the actual recipe and not tease readers by holding back secret ingredients or cooking directions. He should also be asked to do a little work adding something factual and encyclopedic to the article on [[Potato]]es. Just my $0.02. [[User:Dpbsmith\|Dpbsmith]] 13:16, 10 March 2007 (EST)

← Older revision	Revision as of 23:21, December 14, 2008
(No difference)