Counterexamples to Evolution

From Conservapedia
This is an old revision of this page, as edited by CraigC (Talk | contribs) at 20:54, October 26, 2008. It may differ significantly from current revision.

Jump to: navigation, search

The theory of evolution cannot permit any "counterexamples," or examples of things that could not have evolved. As in logic, the existence of merely one counterexample disproves the truth of the rule.

The following are some counterexamples to evolution. If just one is correct, then logically the theory of evolution must be false.

  • beautiful autumn foliage, which lacks any plausible evolutionary explanation
  • the whale, which has no plausible ancestor[1] (Charles Darwin suggested black bears)
  • the eye, which lacks a plausible pathway for incremental evolution[2]
  • bloodclotting, which also lacks a plausible pathway for incremental evolution[3]
  • the immune system is irreducible complex, as without a completely developed one a creature would die from any microbe that it was infected by[4][5]
  • Jellyfish in Hawaii, which swarm to the beaches precisely 9 to 10 days after each full moon[6]
  • cicadas that appear like clockwork every 13 years for some species, and every 17 years for others[7]
  • migratory powers of butterflies and birds[8]
  • The neck of the giraffe.[9]
  • The enormous gaps in the fossil record.
  • The development of feathers, which could not have conceivably "grown" from the scales of dinosaurs[10][11]
  • The flagellum a multi-part cellular motor which fails to function if a single part is removed is the classic example of irreducible complexity and cannot arise according to the theory of evolution.[12]
  • Symbiosis - There are many examples where creatures rely on each other to survive which could not arise through evolution. Flowering plants need bees in order to spread pollen but bees cannot survive without the nectar from flowering plants. Therefore the bees and plants must have arisen at the same time. Likewise, grass cannot survive without a certain fungus that helps it fix nitrogen from the atmosphere and the fungus can't survive without the grass. Again, they must have appeared on earth at the same time.
  • Consciousness - No animal displays self-awareness (such as clothing), morality, tool-making, or self-sacrifice as man does. If man were evolved from lower life forms, we would expect at least some other animals to display these traits. Since they do not, it's clear that man is not simply an animal.

Statistical Approach

If there is merely a 5% chance that any of the foregoing counterexamples is correct, then the odds of at least one of them being correct is at least 49%.[13] As the list grows longer, the odds of the theory of evolution being valid becomes vanishingly small.

References

  1. University of Indiana Natural Sciences Department
  2. Evolution of the eye? Not a chance!
  3. [1]
  4. Behe, Michael J. 1996. Darwin's Black Box, New York: The Free Press, pp. 117-139.
  5. [2]
  6. http://www.aloha.com/~lifeguards/jelyfish.html
  7. http://inside.msj.edu/academics/faculty/kritskg/cicada/faq.html
  8. migration
  9. [3]
  10. http://icb.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/40/4/687.pdf
  11. [4]
  12. [5]
  13. At 14 examples each with a 5% probability of being correct, then the odds of at least one being correct is 0.9514 = 0.49 = 49%