Difference between revisions of "Talk:Sulu"

From Conservapedia
Jump to: navigation, search
(Homosexuality)
(Suggestion: All on one is probably too much)
Line 7: Line 7:
  
 
::You surmised correctly, Philip.  I agree, as a compromise, a single linked page to the Star Trek main article, detailing the characters.  Perhaps detailing the main characters of all three Star Trek series.  And I also agree with your suggestion about putting the religion discussion onto its own, linked page. --[[User:TK|'''₮K''']]<sup>[[User_Talk:TK|/Talk!]]</sup> 19:07, 29 December 2008 (EST)
 
::You surmised correctly, Philip.  I agree, as a compromise, a single linked page to the Star Trek main article, detailing the characters.  Perhaps detailing the main characters of all three Star Trek series.  And I also agree with your suggestion about putting the religion discussion onto its own, linked page. --[[User:TK|'''₮K''']]<sup>[[User_Talk:TK|/Talk!]]</sup> 19:07, 29 December 2008 (EST)
 +
::: There's been ''five'' live-action series.  I'm not sure whether putting them all on the one page is a good idea; one page per series might be better (although a few overlap series).
 +
::: As a minimum, the page(s) should contain details of all the regular characters:
 +
:::{| class="wikitable"
 +
! Original series || Next Generation || Voyager || DS9 || Enterprise
 +
|- style="vertical-align:top"
 +
|
 +
*[[Captain Kirk|Kirk]]
 +
*[[Spock]]
 +
*[[Dr. McCoy|McCoy]]
 +
*[[Scotty]]
 +
*[[Sulu]]
 +
*[[Uhura]]
 +
*[[Chekov]]
 +
|
 +
*Picard
 +
*Riker
 +
*La Forge
 +
*Yar
 +
*Worf
 +
*Beverly Crusher
 +
*Troi
 +
*Data
 +
*Wesley Crusher
 +
|
 +
*Benjamin Sisko
 +
*Odo
 +
*Worf
 +
*Dax
 +
*Jake Sisko
 +
*O'Brien
 +
*Quark
 +
*Bashir
 +
*Kira
 +
|
 +
*Janeway
 +
*Chakotay
 +
*Torres
 +
*Kes
 +
*Paris
 +
*Neelix
 +
*the doctor
 +
*Tuvok
 +
*Seven of Nine
 +
*Kim
 +
|
 +
*Archer
 +
*Phlox
 +
*T'Pol
 +
*Reed
 +
*Mayweather
 +
*Sato
 +
*Tucker
 +
|}
 +
:::And I've missed a few (including at least two from Next Gen).  Plus there's a number of other semi-regular ones that could be included.  Putting all them on one page is going to make for a large page, even given only a paragraph or two each.
 +
::: [[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 10:10, 30 December 2008 (EST)
  
 
== Homosexuality ==
 
== Homosexuality ==

Revision as of 15:10, December 30, 2008

Suggestion

With all respect to the original author, I am wondering if this page should be included into the existing Star Trek page? --₮K/Talk! 18:24, 29 December 2008 (EST)

You don't explain why, so I'll assume that it's to avoid lots of small articles about individual characters?
I don't agree with it being on the Star Trek page. Conservapedia wants concise articles, and the Star Trek article is already a fair size (in fact I think the religion section should be removed to a separate article).
I support this article staying, but an alternative is to have a single article covering all the main characters ("Star Trek characters", "Characters of Star Trek"?) rather than separate articles for each.
Philip J. Rayment 18:58, 29 December 2008 (EST)
You surmised correctly, Philip. I agree, as a compromise, a single linked page to the Star Trek main article, detailing the characters. Perhaps detailing the main characters of all three Star Trek series. And I also agree with your suggestion about putting the religion discussion onto its own, linked page. --₮K/Talk! 19:07, 29 December 2008 (EST)
There's been five live-action series. I'm not sure whether putting them all on the one page is a good idea; one page per series might be better (although a few overlap series).
As a minimum, the page(s) should contain details of all the regular characters:
Original series Next Generation Voyager DS9 Enterprise
  • Picard
  • Riker
  • La Forge
  • Yar
  • Worf
  • Beverly Crusher
  • Troi
  • Data
  • Wesley Crusher
  • Benjamin Sisko
  • Odo
  • Worf
  • Dax
  • Jake Sisko
  • O'Brien
  • Quark
  • Bashir
  • Kira
  • Janeway
  • Chakotay
  • Torres
  • Kes
  • Paris
  • Neelix
  • the doctor
  • Tuvok
  • Seven of Nine
  • Kim
  • Archer
  • Phlox
  • T'Pol
  • Reed
  • Mayweather
  • Sato
  • Tucker
And I've missed a few (including at least two from Next Gen). Plus there's a number of other semi-regular ones that could be included. Putting all them on one page is going to make for a large page, even given only a paragraph or two each.
Philip J. Rayment 10:10, 30 December 2008 (EST)

Homosexuality

I can't find the rule right now, and perhaps we have never adequately documented it (so the following may not be the exact criteria), but we don't include information such as a person being homosexual unless both of the following criteria are satisfied:

  • That their homosexuality is certain.
  • That their homosexuality is a defining aspect of their life, such as them being a homosexual activist.

As far as I'm aware, the second of these points at least is not the case here, which is why I've reverted the claim a second time.

Philip J. Rayment 19:47, 29 December 2008 (EST)

He's been on a gay speaking tour. Is that enough to satisfy #2?[1] - Rod Weathers 19:57, 29 December 2008 (EST)
Perhaps so. Philip J. Rayment 05:42, 30 December 2008 (EST)
He recently took part in a UK reality TV series (set in the Australian rain forest) in which he openly prosyletised for his particular orientation. Bugler 05:50, 30 December 2008 (EST)

Added info

Since this is an article about Sulu, should we really be adding personal info about George Takei? I mean, it makes sense to say Sulu was played by "openly homosexual actor George Takei," but all the information about Takei's "marriage" is terribly out of place. LiamG 02:05, 30 December 2008 (EST)

  • On reflection, Liam, I agree. I didn't exactly see the linkage and article about the real person, George Takei, when I added it.....just read the discussion about his being Gay, which I thought everyone on the planet knew by now, and had a link about the "marriage". I will remove the extra information, and thanks for bringing it up! --₮K/Talk! 02:26, 30 December 2008 (EST)