Changes

1,425 bytes added ,  02:10, October 30, 2007
→‎Brandt / Berlet feud: Berlet asks for help to alleviate criticism.
Line 61: Line 61:  
An ugly sectarian dispute between two far leftist writers reared its head in Wikipedia in 2005 and continues to plague the project. The feud had been dormant, yet unresolved, until the necessity to elevate a “controversial expert” above the level of “partisan and extreme,” which would have precluded using the so-called “expert” as "a source for anything other than himself,” as Wikipedia's ever fluid policies dictate.
 
An ugly sectarian dispute between two far leftist writers reared its head in Wikipedia in 2005 and continues to plague the project. The feud had been dormant, yet unresolved, until the necessity to elevate a “controversial expert” above the level of “partisan and extreme,” which would have precluded using the so-called “expert” as "a source for anything other than himself,” as Wikipedia's ever fluid policies dictate.
   −
[[Chip Berlet]] built a career writing in various far-left [[revolution]]ary publications, including ''[[Guardian]],'' founded by [[KGB]] agent [[Cedric Belfrage]], and whose writers included [[Wilfred Burchett]] who introduce [[Ho Chi Minh]] to American readers, assisted in extracting confessions from [[Korean War]] [[POW]]s, spread [[disinformation]] in its pages about American use of [[germ warfare]] which Soviet Archives now conclusively have shown was a lie manufactured in the [[Kremlin]].  Berlet at one time served on Daniel Brandt’s Public Information Research board of advisers, but Berlet's extreme leftism demands ideological purity from its followers, and Berlet demanded removal of Fletcher Prouty from the Board.  Prouty, a former Air Force colonel, was allegorically portrayed as “Man X” in the [[Oliver Stone]] film [[JFK]], and Berlet considered Prouty a [[fascist]]. The WikiMedia Foundation retained Berlet as a knowledgeable editor to defend against ceaseless barrages from the followers of [[Lyndon LaRouche]]. LaRouche is another fanatical [[leftist]] whose unpeer reviewed idiosyncatic musings are said to carry deep [[Anti-Semitic]] overtones, and is an integral member of [[Democratic Party]] coalition politics.
+
[[Chip Berlet]] built a career writing in various far-left [[revolution]]ary publications, including ''[[Guardian]],'' founded by [[KGB]] agent [[Cedric Belfrage]], and whose writers included [[Wilfred Burchett]] who introduce [[Ho Chi Minh]] to American readers, assisted in extracting confessions from [[Korean War]] [[POW]]s, spread [[disinformation]] in its pages about American use of [[germ warfare]] which Soviet Archives now conclusively have shown was a lie manufactured in the [[Kremlin]].  Berlet at one time served on Daniel Brandt’s Public Information Research board of advisers, but Berlet's extreme leftism demands ideological purity from its followers, and Berlet demanded removal of Fletcher Prouty from the Board.  Prouty, a former Air Force colonel, was allegorically portrayed as “Man X” in the [[Oliver Stone]] film [[JFK]], and Berlet considered Prouty a [[fascist]]. The WikiMedia Foundation retained Berlet as a knowledgeable editor to defend against ceaseless barrages from the followers of [[Lyndon LaRouche]]. LaRouche is another fanatical [[leftist]] whose unpeer reviewed idiosyncratic musings are said to carry deep [[Anti-Semitic]] overtones, and is an integral member of [[Democratic Party]] coalition politics.
   −
Dan Brandt, founder of Namebase, Google Watch, and Wikipedia Watch, removed Berlet from his Board of Advisors in 1991 when Berlet refused to serve on a Board which included, in Berlet's words, "LaRouche-defender Fletcher Prouty"  and in the same breath stated "On the other hand, Brandt is highly critical of the LaRouchians."<ref>[http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/orgs/american/ftp.py?orgs/american//political-research-associates/right.w.left ''Right Woos Left: Populist Party, LaRouchian, and Other Neo-fascist Overtures To Progressives, And Why They Must Be Rejected]'', Chip Berlet, Part 033 ''The JFK Conspiracy'' - November 22, 1993. Retireved from the Nizkor Project, October 29, 2007.</ref>  Brandt responded, "When it came to making a choice between Prouty and Berlet, it was a rather easy decision for me to make."<ref>http://wikipediareview.com/index.php?showtopic=5315&pid=18679&mode=threaded&show=&st=&#entry18679</ref> Berlet furhter undermined Brandt by convincing three other members to quit, and stated, "He was mad."<ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Cberlet/Archive_2005-06_2005-08#Red-baiting_Lie_Article.21</ref>
+
Dan Brandt, founder of Namebase, Google Watch, and Wikipedia Watch, removed Berlet from his Board of Advisors in 1991 when Berlet refused to serve on a Board which included, in Berlet's words, "LaRouche-defender Fletcher Prouty” and in the same breath stated "On the other hand, Brandt is highly critical of the LaRouchians."<ref>[http://www.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi/orgs/american/ftp.py?orgs/american//political-research-associates/right.w.left ''Right Woos Left: Populist Party, LaRouchian, and Other Neo-fascist Overtures To Progressives, And Why They Must Be Rejected]'', Chip Berlet, Part 033 ''The JFK Conspiracy'' - November 22, 1993. Retrieved from the Nizkor Project, October 29, 2007.</ref>  Brandt responded, "When it came to making a choice between Prouty and Berlet, it was a rather easy decision for me to make."<ref>http://wikipediareview.com/index.php?showtopic=5315&pid=18679&mode=threaded&show=&st=&#entry18679</ref> Berlet further undermined Brandt by convincing three other members to quit, and added, "He was mad."<ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Cberlet/Archive_2005-06_2005-08#Red-baiting_Lie_Article.21</ref>
 +
 
 +
'''Neutral Point of View''' requires,
 +
{{Cquote|without bias all significant views (that have been published by reliable sources). This is non-negotiable and expected on all articles.}}
 +
Berlet complained about criticism in his biographical entry,<ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Cberlet/Archive_2005-06_2005-08#Red-baiting_Lie_Article.21</ref> and the organization he is associated with, [[Political Research Associates]].<ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Political_Research_Associates&diff=prev&oldid=24242896</ref>  One critic was blasted in the article mainspace by Berlet with an unsourced, unspecified countercharge of being "unethical;" when an editor asked if the charge could be substantiated he was rebuked with a charge of "harassment."<ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Talk:Chip_Berlet/Archive_2#Laird_Wilcox</ref> Another reliable source in the article read,
 +
{{Cquote|one leftist writer mentions Berlet’s “crusade” against Progressives who stray from Berlet's ideological fever swamps by working with non-leftist groups. In a fascinating conclusion, the leftist commentator warns that Berlet “may try to undermine your work and isolate you.” }}
 +
Berlet stated, "This complaint was written by Daniel Brandt," and a Daniel Brandt entry on Wikipedia soon was created.<ref>http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User_talk:Cberlet/Archive_2005-06_2005-08#Red-baiting_Lie_Article.21</ref>
    
==Essjay Scandal==
 
==Essjay Scandal==
Block, Siteadmin, SkipCaptcha, Upload, Automoderated users, delete, edit, move, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, protect, rollback, Administrators, template
293,647

edits