46
edits
Changes
Talk:Private property (view source)
Revision as of 23:40, November 27, 2007
, 23:40, November 27, 2007→Private property = single owner
You are in error with respect to American law. "Joint ownership" never refers to private property. If I may direct your attention to the LEGAL DEFINITION, estate (real and personal property) is held with qualified ownership by two or more persons OR when the ownership is limited in any fashion. In contrast PRIVATE PROPERTY is absolutely owned by an individual. The U.S. constitution specifically protects private property ownership, while not extending any protection to estate. Similarly, state constitutions delegate taxing power over estate but do not refer to private property. (see Ad Valorem Taxation)
You are in error with respect to American law. "Joint ownership" never refers to private property. If I may direct your attention to the LEGAL DEFINITION, estate (real and personal property) is held with qualified ownership by two or more persons OR when the ownership is limited in any fashion. In contrast PRIVATE PROPERTY is absolutely owned by an individual. The U.S. constitution specifically protects private property ownership, while not extending any protection to estate. Similarly, state constitutions delegate taxing power over estate but do not refer to private property. (see Ad Valorem Taxation)
As long as you fail to comprehend the distinction, you will mix apples and oranges.
As long as you fail to comprehend the distinction, you will mix apples and oranges.
: Your comments are sufficiently alien to what I was taught in law school that I don't believe unsourced assertions can advance the discussion any further. If you wish to persist in your contentions, please provide citations to whatever authority you believe support them. Please don't construe this as a personal attack; I'm simply pointing out that it is obvious that we are each opperating from a number of assumptions (or, at least using definitions)that the other does not accept. Rational debate can't procede to conclusions until we are agreed on our premises. [[User:QBeam]] 6:35PM (EST) Nov. 27, 2007.
--[[User:Jetgraphics|Jetgraphics]] 18:00, 27 November 2007 (EST)
--[[User:Jetgraphics|Jetgraphics]] 18:00, 27 November 2007 (EST)