Changes

51 bytes removed ,  22:35, March 11, 2008
m
re-wikify
Line 1: Line 1:  
There have been a number of proposals regarding the '''origin of life''' on earth.  However, the various proposals fall into two schools of thought.
 
There have been a number of proposals regarding the '''origin of life''' on earth.  However, the various proposals fall into two schools of thought.
−
One, held by [[Creationism|creationists]], is that life originated [[Supernatural|supernaturally]].
+
One, held by [[Creationism|creationists]], is that life originated [[supernatural]]ly.
 
The other school of thought is that non-life became life solely by means of natural processes.  This is commonly referred to as ''abiogenesis''.<ref>http://www.creationresearch.org/crsq/articles/36/36_4/abiogenesis.html</ref>
 
The other school of thought is that non-life became life solely by means of natural processes.  This is commonly referred to as ''abiogenesis''.<ref>http://www.creationresearch.org/crsq/articles/36/36_4/abiogenesis.html</ref>
 
The proposal that first life came about through natural processes has not fared well in recent times.  Dr. [[Walter Bradley]] said: "The optimism of the 1950's is gone. The mood at the 1999 international conference of the origin of life was described as grim - full of frustration, pessimism, and desperation."<ref name="CfF">Quoted in Strobel, Lee, [http://books.google.com/books?id=caGCTtPi-aMC&pg=PA107&lpg=PA107&dq=mood+and+conference+and+origin+and+life+and+bradley+and+grim&source=web&ots=iyVq9fDDDR&sig=ub92i66wAgY0UslPEM1WLlxSl9M The case for Faith], p.107.</ref>
 
The proposal that first life came about through natural processes has not fared well in recent times.  Dr. [[Walter Bradley]] said: "The optimism of the 1950's is gone. The mood at the 1999 international conference of the origin of life was described as grim - full of frustration, pessimism, and desperation."<ref name="CfF">Quoted in Strobel, Lee, [http://books.google.com/books?id=caGCTtPi-aMC&pg=PA107&lpg=PA107&dq=mood+and+conference+and+origin+and+life+and+bradley+and+grim&source=web&ots=iyVq9fDDDR&sig=ub92i66wAgY0UslPEM1WLlxSl9M The case for Faith], p.107.</ref>
Line 12: Line 12:  
==Some Specific Problems for Naturalistic Explanations of the Origin of Life==
 
==Some Specific Problems for Naturalistic Explanations of the Origin of Life==
 
The attempt to explain the origin of life faces numerous difficult problems which is why the theory has not fared well in recent times:
 
The attempt to explain the origin of life faces numerous difficult problems which is why the theory has not fared well in recent times:
−
#'''Chicken or the Egg problem regarding [[DNA]] and [[protein]]s''': John Horgan wrote: "Many investigators now consider [[nucleic acids]] to be much more plausible candidates for the first self-replicating [[molecule]]s. The work of [[James Watson|Watson]] and [[Francis Crick|Crick]] and others has shown that proteins are formed according to the instructions coded in DNA. But there is a hitch. DNA cannot do its work, including forming more DNA, without the help of [[catalytic proteins]], or [[enzyme]]s. In short, proteins cannot form without DNA, but neither can DNA form without proteins. To those pondering the origin of life, it is a classic chicken-and-egg problem: Which came first, proteins or DNA?" - (John Horgan,[science writer], "In The Beginning...," ''[[Scientific American]]'', Vol. 264, No. 2, February 1991, pp.100-109, p.103)"<ref>http://members.iinet.net.au/~sejones/orignl01.html#orgnflfmjrprblmschcknndgg</ref>
+
#'''Chicken or the Egg problem regarding [[DNA]] and [[protein]]s''': John Horgan wrote: "Many investigators now consider [[nucleic acids]] to be much more plausible candidates for the first self-replicating [[molecule]]s. The work of [[James Watson|Watson]] and [[Francis Crick|Crick]] and others has shown that proteins are formed according to the instructions coded in DNA. But there is a hitch. DNA cannot do its work, including forming more DNA, without the help of [[catalytic protein]]s, or [[enzyme]]s. In short, proteins cannot form without DNA, but neither can DNA form without proteins. To those pondering the origin of life, it is a classic chicken-and-egg problem: Which came first, proteins or DNA?" - (John Horgan,[science writer], "In The Beginning...," ''[[Scientific American]]'', Vol. 264, No. 2, February 1991, pp.100-109, p.103)"<ref>http://members.iinet.net.au/~sejones/orignl01.html#orgnflfmjrprblmschcknndgg</ref>
 
#Complexity of the [[cell]]: [[Molecule|Molecular]] [[biology|biologist]] [[Michael Denton]] wrote regarding the complexity of the cell: "To grasp the reality of life as it has been revealed by [[molecular biology]], we must magnify a [[cell]] a thousand million times until it is twenty [[kilometer]]s in diameter and resembles a giant airship large enough to cover a great city like [[London]] or [[New York City|New York]]. What we would then see would be an object of unparalleled complexity and adaptive design. On the surface of the cell we would see millions of openings, like the port holes of a vast space ship, opening and closing to allow a continual stream of materials to flow in and out. If we were to enter one of these openings we would find ourselves in a world of supreme technology and bewildering complexity... Is it really credible that random processes could have constructed a reality, the smallest element of which-a functional [[protein]] or [[gene]] - is complex beyond our own creative capacities, a reality which is the very antithesis of chance, which excels in every sense anything produced by the intelligence of man?"<ref>Michael Denton, Evolution: A Theory in Crisis, Burnett Books, London, 1985, pages 328 and 342</ref>
 
#Complexity of the [[cell]]: [[Molecule|Molecular]] [[biology|biologist]] [[Michael Denton]] wrote regarding the complexity of the cell: "To grasp the reality of life as it has been revealed by [[molecular biology]], we must magnify a [[cell]] a thousand million times until it is twenty [[kilometer]]s in diameter and resembles a giant airship large enough to cover a great city like [[London]] or [[New York City|New York]]. What we would then see would be an object of unparalleled complexity and adaptive design. On the surface of the cell we would see millions of openings, like the port holes of a vast space ship, opening and closing to allow a continual stream of materials to flow in and out. If we were to enter one of these openings we would find ourselves in a world of supreme technology and bewildering complexity... Is it really credible that random processes could have constructed a reality, the smallest element of which-a functional [[protein]] or [[gene]] - is complex beyond our own creative capacities, a reality which is the very antithesis of chance, which excels in every sense anything produced by the intelligence of man?"<ref>Michael Denton, Evolution: A Theory in Crisis, Burnett Books, London, 1985, pages 328 and 342</ref>
−
#[[Catch 22]] problem regarding [[oxygen]] and the early [[earth]]: The [[creation science]] organization [[Answers in Genesis]] cites the "catch 22" dilemna regarding oxygen on the early earth in regards to a hypothesized naturalistic origin of life: "If we were to grant the evolutionists’ assumption of no oxygen in the original [[atmosphere]], another fatal problem arises. Since the [[ozone]] is made of oxygen, it would not exist; and the [[ultraviolet]] rays from the [[sun]] would destroy any biological molecules. This presents a no-win situation for the evolution model. If there was oxygen, life could not start. If there was no oxygen, life could not start. Michael Denton notes: What we have is sort of a “Catch 22” situation. If we have oxygen we have no [[organic compounds]], but if we don’t have oxygen we have none either."<ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/wow/can-natural-processes-explain</ref>
+
#[[Catch 22]] problem regarding [[oxygen]] and the early [[earth]]: The [[creation science]] organization [[Answers in Genesis]] cites the "catch 22" dilemna regarding oxygen on the early earth in regards to a hypothesized naturalistic origin of life: "If we were to grant the evolutionists’ assumption of no oxygen in the original [[atmosphere]], another fatal problem arises. Since the [[ozone]] is made of oxygen, it would not exist; and the [[ultraviolet]] rays from the [[sun]] would destroy any biological molecules. This presents a no-win situation for the evolution model. If there was oxygen, life could not start. If there was no oxygen, life could not start. Michael Denton notes: What we have is sort of a “Catch 22” situation. If we have oxygen we have no [[organic compound]]s, but if we don’t have oxygen we have none either."<ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/articles/wow/can-natural-processes-explain</ref>
 
#Implausibility of the [[RNA World]] hypothesis.<ref>http://www.arn.org/docs/odesign/od171/rnaworld171.htm</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/tj/v11/i1/enzymes.asp</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/tools/Quotes/cairns-smith_RNA.asp</ref>
 
#Implausibility of the [[RNA World]] hypothesis.<ref>http://www.arn.org/docs/odesign/od171/rnaworld171.htm</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/tj/v11/i1/enzymes.asp</ref><ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/home/area/tools/Quotes/cairns-smith_RNA.asp</ref>
 
#[[Chirality]] problem<ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/tj/v12/i3/chirality.asp</ref>
 
#[[Chirality]] problem<ref>http://www.answersingenesis.org/tj/v12/i3/chirality.asp</ref>
Line 21: Line 21:  
== Philosophical Presuppositions and Origin of Life Scenarios ==
 
== Philosophical Presuppositions and Origin of Life Scenarios ==
   −
Noted [[Physics|physicist]] and [[bioinformatics|bioinformatician]] [[Hubert Yockey]], who worked under [[Robert Oppenheimer]] on the [[Manhatten Project]] wrote the following regarding the crucial role the [[Philosophical|philosophical]] presuppositions play in the origin of life issue:
+
Noted [[Physics|physicist]] and [[bioinformatics|bioinformatician]] [[Hubert Yockey]], who worked under [[Robert Oppenheimer]] on the [[Manhatten Project]] wrote the following regarding the crucial role the [[philosophical]] presuppositions play in the origin of life issue:
−
{{cquote|Faith in the infallible and comprehensive doctrines of [[Dialectical materialism|dialectic materialism]] plays a crucial role in origin of life scenarios, and especially in [[exobiology]] and its ultimate consequence the doctrine of advanced extra-terrestrial civilization. That life must exist somewhere in the solar system on ‘suitable planets elsewhere’ is widely and tenaciously believed in spite of lack of evidence or even abundant evidence to the contrary.<ref>http://www.genesispark.org/genpark/spongen/spongen.htm Reprint of an [[Creation Research Quarterly]] September 2001 article ''The Spontaneous Generation Hypothesis'' by David P. Woetzel</ref>}}
+
{{cquote|Faith in the infallible and comprehensive doctrines of [[dialectic materialism]] plays a crucial role in origin of life scenarios, and especially in [[exobiology]] and its ultimate consequence the doctrine of advanced extra-terrestrial civilization. That life must exist somewhere in the solar system on ‘suitable planets elsewhere’ is widely and tenaciously believed in spite of lack of evidence or even abundant evidence to the contrary.<ref>http://www.genesispark.org/genpark/spongen/spongen.htm Reprint of an [[Creation Research Quarterly]] September 2001 article ''The Spontaneous Generation Hypothesis'' by David P. Woetzel</ref>}}
    
Yockey's statement regarding the philosophical presuppositions playing a crucial role in origin of life scenarios can be seen in regards to Sir [[Francis Crick]] the Nobel Prize winning biologist who was the British co-discoverer of the structure of [[DNA]].  Crick has described himself as an [[agnostic]] with "a strong inclination towards [[atheism]]."<ref>Francis Crick, What Mad Pursuit: a Personal View of Scientific Discovery, Basic Books reprint edition, 1990, ISBN 0-465-09138-5, p. 145.</ref> In 1973, Francis Crick and the chemist [[Leslie Orgel]] published an article in the [[International Journal of Solar System Studies]] (Icarus) which posited that life may have arrived on [[earth]] by a process they called "[[Directed panspermia|Directed Panspermia]]".<ref>http://www.spacedaily.com/news/life-04zzz.html</ref> The abstract for the aforemention Icarus article states that Directed Pamspermia is a "theory that organisms were deliberately transmitted to the earth by intelligent beings on another planet."<ref>http://www.spacedaily.com/news/life-04zzz.html</ref>  
 
Yockey's statement regarding the philosophical presuppositions playing a crucial role in origin of life scenarios can be seen in regards to Sir [[Francis Crick]] the Nobel Prize winning biologist who was the British co-discoverer of the structure of [[DNA]].  Crick has described himself as an [[agnostic]] with "a strong inclination towards [[atheism]]."<ref>Francis Crick, What Mad Pursuit: a Personal View of Scientific Discovery, Basic Books reprint edition, 1990, ISBN 0-465-09138-5, p. 145.</ref> In 1973, Francis Crick and the chemist [[Leslie Orgel]] published an article in the [[International Journal of Solar System Studies]] (Icarus) which posited that life may have arrived on [[earth]] by a process they called "[[Directed panspermia|Directed Panspermia]]".<ref>http://www.spacedaily.com/news/life-04zzz.html</ref> The abstract for the aforemention Icarus article states that Directed Pamspermia is a "theory that organisms were deliberately transmitted to the earth by intelligent beings on another planet."<ref>http://www.spacedaily.com/news/life-04zzz.html</ref>  
5,190

edits