Difference between revisions of "Talk:Women in the military"

From Conservapedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 9: Line 9:
 
:::I don't understand how (1) this is an insult or (2) how it being insult means it is untrue or irrelevant. Are you trying to improve the article, or are you just making a point? --[[User:Ed Poor|Ed Poor]] <sup>[[User talk:Ed Poor|Talk]]</sup> 11:37, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
 
:::I don't understand how (1) this is an insult or (2) how it being insult means it is untrue or irrelevant. Are you trying to improve the article, or are you just making a point? --[[User:Ed Poor|Ed Poor]] <sup>[[User talk:Ed Poor|Talk]]</sup> 11:37, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
  
−
:::: You're repeating old, unproven stereotypes about women in combat roles, which many women serving in those roles would find insulting, I'm sure.  As you can see by now I'm adding valid-sourced comments to the article, and not just talking.  <br /><br />Also, I have to question the validity of the sources you're using.  You back up your comment about women being ineffective in the Israeli army by citing an essay, where that assertion is made but not backed up with any evidence.  The same goes for your reference for men being better soldiers than women - linking to an essay that makes generalizations does not make those generalizations credible. --[[User:DinsdaleP|DinsdaleP]] 12:02, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
+
:::: You're repeating old, unproven stereotypes about women in combat roles, which many women serving in those roles would find insulting, I'm sure.  As you can see by now I'm adding valid-sourced comments to the article, and not just talking.  <br />Also, I have to question the validity of the sources you're using.  You back up your comment about women being ineffective in the Israeli army by citing an essay, where that assertion is made but not backed up with any evidence.  The same goes for your reference for men being better soldiers than women - linking to an essay that makes generalizations does not make those generalizations credible. --[[User:DinsdaleP|DinsdaleP]] 12:02, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
 +
 
 +
==Women in the Israeli Army==
 +
 
 +
I had deleted the comment about Israeli women being pulled from combat over being ineffective because the source used had no references itself that validated the assertion of Israeli female sodiers performing ineffectively - it was only asserted.  In response, I found the following source showing that the Israeli military itself is recommending that women serve in combat roles.<ref>[http://www.iht.com/articles/ap/2007/09/17/africa/ME-GEN-Israel-Women-in-Uniform.php] Israeli military study calls for opening all combat roles to women</ref>  --[[User:DinsdaleP|DinsdaleP]] 12:29, 1 May 2008 (EDT)

Revision as of 16:29, May 1, 2008

Where is the evidence?

Ed, while obvious statements like "the sky is blue" don't need citations, in an encyclopedia website it's wrong to make assertions like some the ones here and not back them up with valid references. Where is the evidence that women are less effective in fighting than men, or the reference for stating that their use by the Polish military was a failure? --DinsdaleP 11:11, 1 May 2008 (EDT)

You can fact-tag any assertion which requires a citation. --Ed Poor Talk 11:13, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
More to the point, using Kelly Flynn as a representative example of women pilots is an insult to the skills and accomplishments of the many fine, dedicated women putting their lives on the line for us each day. (No male serviceman was ever discharged for adultery? There are no female pilots who are qualified without retests?) Support the troops, Ed. They deserve better than this.

I'm going to do some research and add to this article, if that's okay with you. I want to point out where women have made significant contributions to the military, and add cited references to their effectiveness in the Israeli army to provide an objective counterpoint to the Polish statement. --DinsdaleP 11:19, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
I don't understand how (1) this is an insult or (2) how it being insult means it is untrue or irrelevant. Are you trying to improve the article, or are you just making a point? --Ed Poor Talk 11:37, 1 May 2008 (EDT)
You're repeating old, unproven stereotypes about women in combat roles, which many women serving in those roles would find insulting, I'm sure. As you can see by now I'm adding valid-sourced comments to the article, and not just talking.
Also, I have to question the validity of the sources you're using. You back up your comment about women being ineffective in the Israeli army by citing an essay, where that assertion is made but not backed up with any evidence. The same goes for your reference for men being better soldiers than women - linking to an essay that makes generalizations does not make those generalizations credible. --DinsdaleP 12:02, 1 May 2008 (EDT)

Women in the Israeli Army

I had deleted the comment about Israeli women being pulled from combat over being ineffective because the source used had no references itself that validated the assertion of Israeli female sodiers performing ineffectively - it was only asserted. In response, I found the following source showing that the Israeli military itself is recommending that women serve in combat roles.[1] --DinsdaleP 12:29, 1 May 2008 (EDT)

  1. ↑ [1] Israeli military study calls for opening all combat roles to women