Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 156: Line 156:  
==The Drowning Man==
 
==The Drowning Man==
   −
No personal offense to the author, but I'd suggest removing this story completely because it doesn't convey anything positive despite the attempt at teaching about helping people to help themselves.  When a person is drowning it's because they can't swim or tread water, and the reactions in the story are just awful.  Can you imagine a lifeguard throwing a short line and expecting the victim to close the gap, or throwing a line and letting it go?  All this story does is make the conservative look unbelievably callous and the liberal unbelievably stupid, so if the intention is to make a point in a meaningful, believable way then this needs a fresh start.
+
No personal offense to the author, but I'd suggest removing this story completely because it doesn't convey anything positive despite the attempt at teaching about helping people to help themselves.  When a person is drowning it's because they can't swim or tread water, and the reactions in the story are just awful.  Can you imagine a lifeguard throwing a short line and expecting the victim to close the gap, or throwing a line and letting it go?  All this story does is make the conservative look unbelievably callous and the liberal unbelievably stupid, so if the intention is to make a point in a meaningful, believable way then this needs a fresh start.--[[User:DinsdaleP|DinsdaleP]] 16:15, 13 June 2008 (EDT)
1,516

edits

Navigation menu