Difference between revisions of "Talk:Israel"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
:The article is just a long list of war-related grievances. None of it has a source, and most of it is false. If you want to write an article on the conflict between Israel and its neighbors, then it would have to have verifiable info. This is an article on Israel, and should describe Israel. | :The article is just a long list of war-related grievances. None of it has a source, and most of it is false. If you want to write an article on the conflict between Israel and its neighbors, then it would have to have verifiable info. This is an article on Israel, and should describe Israel. | ||
: Almost everything is false. The deleted portion starts with "In 1948, it once again became a sovereign nation largely due to terrorist tactics". Not true. Israel became a sovereign nation as a result of a UN action. [[User:RSchlafly|RSchlafly]] 13:08, 12 March 2007 (EDT) | : Almost everything is false. The deleted portion starts with "In 1948, it once again became a sovereign nation largely due to terrorist tactics". Not true. Israel became a sovereign nation as a result of a UN action. [[User:RSchlafly|RSchlafly]] 13:08, 12 March 2007 (EDT) | ||
| + | |||
| + | :: ... but would almost certainly not have been handed over to the UN if groups such as Haganah, the Stern gang, and Irgun had not carried out terrorist attacks against the British; the King David hotel bombing, which was the most obvious example, killed 91 people - I would call that terrorist tactics. [[User:Wikinterpreter|Wikinterpreter]] | ||
Revision as of 18:56, March 19, 2007
I was trying to fine tune this entry but I think I ruined it
The entry on the Israeli/Palestinian conflict seems very one sided...
I see that you are guilty of doing exactly what you complain about on Wikipedia.
I edited this entry adding factual and easily verifiable information and someone came along and deleted the entire thing, claiming that my edits were not true.
I would like to know what was not true about the facts I listed. Every single thing I wrote is easily verified.
- The article is just a long list of war-related grievances. None of it has a source, and most of it is false. If you want to write an article on the conflict between Israel and its neighbors, then it would have to have verifiable info. This is an article on Israel, and should describe Israel.
- Almost everything is false. The deleted portion starts with "In 1948, it once again became a sovereign nation largely due to terrorist tactics". Not true. Israel became a sovereign nation as a result of a UN action. RSchlafly 13:08, 12 March 2007 (EDT)
- ... but would almost certainly not have been handed over to the UN if groups such as Haganah, the Stern gang, and Irgun had not carried out terrorist attacks against the British; the King David hotel bombing, which was the most obvious example, killed 91 people - I would call that terrorist tactics. Wikinterpreter