Changes

→‎Too Much mention of religion: I disagree with your assumptions, I think
Line 82: Line 82:     
:::If growth requires that we let them claim Ben Franklin wasn't a Deist when he himself says that he was, is that something that really ought to be encouraged?  If it means endorsing the selective quoting of passages where he acknowledges the social value of religions and moral systems, Christianity in particular, to endorse the idea that he was a practicing Christian himself, that should just be allowed without comment?  Growth means we allow the distorted suggestion that Franklin worshipped Jesus when not only did he doubt Christ's divinity, but also believed that Christ Himself was a Deist?  We should encourage this?
 
:::If growth requires that we let them claim Ben Franklin wasn't a Deist when he himself says that he was, is that something that really ought to be encouraged?  If it means endorsing the selective quoting of passages where he acknowledges the social value of religions and moral systems, Christianity in particular, to endorse the idea that he was a practicing Christian himself, that should just be allowed without comment?  Growth means we allow the distorted suggestion that Franklin worshipped Jesus when not only did he doubt Christ's divinity, but also believed that Christ Himself was a Deist?  We should encourage this?
 +
 +
That's not what I meant. We should allow contributors to cite arguments for and against any view of Benjamin's Franklin's religious outlook.
 +
 +
A typical argument of biased liberals is to claim that no one disagrees with them. If that doesn't hold water, they say no one worth listening disagrees, etc.
 +
 +
A balanced treatment would simply note all expressed viewpoints and let the reader decide which are more credible. For example, suppose all you knew about global warming was 4 statements: two by politicians, one by a scientists speaking for himself, and one by an international panel convened by the United Nations:
 +
#Former VP: warming is caused by humans and we must stop it
 +
#Senator: that's a hoax, and we should ignore it
 +
#Scientist: [[Anthropogenic global warming]] is not a matter of scientific consensus, and proponents of immediate action exaggerate the risks of further warming
 +
#IPCC: warming is caused by humans and we must stop it
 +
 +
On this basis alone, how would you choose?
    
==References==
 
==References==
 
<references/>
 
<references/>
Siteadmin, Check users, nsTeam1RO, nsTeam1RW, nsTeam1_talkRO, nsTeam1_talkRW, oversight, Administrators
30,650

edits