{{cquote|that is so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive, and that so undermines and detracts from the victims’ educational experience, that the victim-students are effectively denied equal access to an institution’s resources and opportunities.}}
{{cquote|that is so severe, pervasive, and objectively offensive, and that so undermines and detracts from the victims’ educational experience, that the victim-students are effectively denied equal access to an institution’s resources and opportunities.}}
−
The Court reached this definition in an effort to balance the free speech rights of the accused against the right of students to get an education. However, the Department of Education adopted a much broader definition that would allow students, faculty or staff to be punished if a "hostile environment" was created for the student, regardless of how much the accused contributed to that environment.
+
The Court reached this definition in an effort to balance the free speech rights of the accused against the right of students to get an education. However, from 1999 to 2017, the Department of Education adopted a much broader definition that would allow students, faculty or staff to be punished if a "hostile environment" was created for the student, regardless of how much the accused contributed to that environment.
The Trump Administration, rescinded the "Dear Colleague" letter and conducted a full notice and comment rulemaking. Opponents of reform sought to delay the rulemaking by submitting 250,000 individual comments and seeking in-person meetings with the federal employees working on the rules. Nonetheless, the Department of Education issued final rules to be effective August 14, 2020. A number of advocacy groups then sought court injunctions to block the final rule from going into effect, without success. Meanwhile, schools seeking to punish students for making "politically incorrect" statements, adopted new Title IX rules that follows the definition of sexual harrassment from the final rule, but then defines "creating a hostile environment" as a separate violation. Although the Obama Administration force schools to apply the "preponderance of the evidence" standard, the final rule lifted that unfair requirement and instead merely required a school to use the same standard when judging students, faculty and staff.
The Trump Administration, rescinded the "Dear Colleague" letter and conducted a full notice and comment rulemaking. Opponents of reform sought to delay the rulemaking by submitting 250,000 individual comments and seeking in-person meetings with the federal employees working on the rules. Nonetheless, the Department of Education issued final rules to be effective August 14, 2020. A number of advocacy groups then sought court injunctions to block the final rule from going into effect, without success. Meanwhile, schools seeking to punish students for making "politically incorrect" statements, adopted new Title IX rules that follows the definition of sexual harrassment from the final rule, but then defines "creating a hostile environment" as a separate violation. Although the Obama Administration force schools to apply the "preponderance of the evidence" standard, the final rule lifted that unfair requirement and instead merely required a school to use the same standard when judging students, faculty and staff.