Changes

3,738 bytes added ,  21:16, October 20, 2010
→‎New York: Added legal repercussions, expanded section
Line 19: Line 19:  
==New York==
 
==New York==
   −
The legislature of [[New York]] was permit any abortionist with a medical license to ply his trade legally. Ketchum closed down his Michigan hospital, packed up his pitted and blood stained instruments, and moved on to New York. When the New York law, allowing abortion on demand up to 24 weeks, went into effect on July 1, 1970, Ketchum was ready. He opened his legal abortion practice in a [[hotel]] suite in Buffalo.  
+
The legislature of [[New York]] had voted to permit any abortionist with a medical license to ply his trade legally. Ketchum closed down his Michigan hospital, packed up his pitted and blood stained instruments, and moved on to New York. When the New York law, allowing abortion on demand up to 24 weeks, went into effect on July 1, 1970, Ketchum was ready. He opened his legal abortion practice in a [[hotel]] suite in Buffalo.  
   −
There, Ketchum would have felt free to relax his standards. Abortionists were flaunting safety standards with impunity. Practices such as injecting patients with saline then sending them home to abort were noted by officials, but no arrests were resulting.
+
There, Ketchum would have felt free to relax his standards. Abortionists were flaunting safety standards with impunity. Practices such as injecting patients with [[saline abortion | saline]] then sending them home to abort were noted by officials, but no arrests were resulting.
   −
Little is known about the first year of Ketchum's New York practice, but by May of 1971 his luck was running out.  On May 28, Ketchum did a D&C abortion under general anesthesia on Ellen K. Lawler of New Baltimore, MI, in his Buffalo office. Only later, at an undisclosed time, did Mrs. Lawler discover that Ketchum had lacerated her uterus, anterior cul-de-sac, right broad ligament, and peritoneum. He had told her the abortion had been uncomplicated. Such severe injuries in a criminal abortion patient would have resulted in an arrest. But this was New York, abortion was legal, and although Mrs. Lawler suffered ill effects from Ketchum's foul-up, Ketchum himself was able to carry on.<ref>New York Supreme Court, County of Erie, Index No. 62821</ref>
+
Little is known about the first year of Ketchum's New York practice, but by May of 1971 his luck was running out.  On May 28, Ketchum did a D&C abortion under general anesthesia on Ellen K. Lawler of New Baltimore, Michigan, in his Buffalo office. Only later, at an undisclosed time, did Mrs. Lawler discover that Ketchum had lacerated her uterus, anterior cul-de-sac, right broad ligament, and peritoneum. He had told her the abortion had been uncomplicated. Such severe injuries in a criminal abortion patient would have resulted in an arrest. But this was New York, abortion was legal, and although Mrs. Lawler suffered ill effects from Ketchum's foul-up, Ketchum himself was able to carry on.<ref>New York Supreme Court, County of Erie, Index No. 62821</ref>
    
Ketchum decided to do [[hysterotomy abortions]] in his office. A hysterotomy abortion is simply a c-section intending to deliver a baby too premature to survive, then let the child die.  
 
Ketchum decided to do [[hysterotomy abortions]] in his office. A hysterotomy abortion is simply a c-section intending to deliver a baby too premature to survive, then let the child die.  
   −
Then Margaret Louise Smith, who had been exposed to [[rubella]] when pregnant with her third child, traveled from Michigan to Buffalo for an outpatient abortion. Ketchum, aided by his 23-year-old wife Judith, performed a vaginal hysterotomy abortion on 25-year-old Margaret at about 10AM on June 16, 1971, then left her virtually unattended until her friend Billy Ray Ellenberg returned to the office at about 2PM. Ellenberg found Margaret pale and breathing with difficulty. He pleaded with Ketchum to take some action. Ketchum attempted to treat Margaret in his office before summoning paramedics, who were unable to revive her. Margaret was pronounced dead on arrival at a hospital across the street at around 4PM. Although Margaret's [[vagina]] had been sutured, removal of those sutures revealed a vast laceration involving the entire [[cervix]], lower [[uterus]], and broad ligament. Margaret had been slashed internally and left to bleed to death.<ref>Journal of ACOG March 1974; New York State Journal of Medicine October 1975</ref>
+
Then Margaret Louise Smith, who had been exposed to [[rubella]] when pregnant with her third child, traveled from Michigan to Buffalo for an outpatient abortion. Ketchum, aided by his 23-year-old wife Judith, performed a vaginal hysterotomy abortion on 25-year-old Margaret at about 10:00 a.m. on June 16, 1971, then left her virtually unattended until her friend Billy Ray Ellenberg returned to the office at about 2:00 p.m. Ellenberg found Margaret pale and breathing with difficulty. He pleaded with Ketchum to take some action. Ketchum attempted to treat Margaret in his office before summoning paramedics, who were unable to revive her. Margaret was pronounced dead on arrival at a hospital across the street at around 4PM. Although Margaret's [[vagina]] had been sutured, removal of those sutures revealed a vast laceration involving the entire [[cervix]], lower [[uterus]], and broad ligament. Margaret had been slashed internally and left to bleed to death.<ref>''Journal of the American College of Obstetrics and Gynecology'', March 1974; ''New York State Journal of Medicine'' October 1975</ref>
   −
Still no action was taken to shut Ketchum's practice down. He wasn't even arraigned until January of 1972 - six months after Margaret's death -- and then was freed on $10,000 bond. There is no evidence that Margaret's death in any way prompted Ketchum to improve his practice or institute safety measures. He went about his business while his attorney handled the matter. He still had the criminal abortion charges pending in Michigan, but after two and a half years of trying to get uncooperative and elusive witnesses to show up, prosecutors dropped one of the charges. Two others were pending. New York health authorities continued to have their hands full with abortion deaths.  
+
Still no action was taken to shut Ketchum's practice down. He wasn't even arraigned until January of 1972 - six months after Margaret's death -- and then was freed on $10,000 bond. There is no evidence that Margaret's death in any way prompted Ketchum to improve his practice or institute safety measures. He went about his business while his attorney handled the matter. He still had the criminal abortion charges pending in Michigan, but after two and a half years of trying to get uncooperative and elusive witnesses to show up, prosecutors dropped one of the charges. Two others were pending. New York health authorities continued to have their hands full with abortion deaths caused by other legal practitioners.  
   −
And in the mean time he had brought his total reported abortions to 862. One of those abortions was performed on Carol Schaner on October 24, slightly more than four months after Margaret Smith's death.
+
And in the mean time Ketchum had brought his total reported abortions to 862. One of those abortions was performed on Carol Schaner on October 24, slightly more than four months after Margaret Smith's death.
    
Carol, age 37, had traveled from Ohio for her abortion. After Ketchum released her, she went into [[shock]], and died in a New York hospital. At [[autopsy]], it was discovered that the case eerily echoed Margaret's injuries. Ketchum had sutured Carol's cervix shut, hiding a laceration through the cervix and uterus and into a uterine artery. Like Margaret Smith, Carol Schaner had simply been allowed to bleed to death.
 
Carol, age 37, had traveled from Ohio for her abortion. After Ketchum released her, she went into [[shock]], and died in a New York hospital. At [[autopsy]], it was discovered that the case eerily echoed Margaret's injuries. Ketchum had sutured Carol's cervix shut, hiding a laceration through the cervix and uterus and into a uterine artery. Like Margaret Smith, Carol Schaner had simply been allowed to bleed to death.
 +
 +
==Legal Repercussions==
    
Across the nation, abortionists were getting old criminal abortion cases dropped -- after all, the laws were unconstitutional.
 
Across the nation, abortionists were getting old criminal abortion cases dropped -- after all, the laws were unconstitutional.
   −
Even convictions for criminal abortion deaths were being thrown out -- Richard Mucie was able to have his conviction for the February 1968 abortion death of Nancy Ward in Missouri overturned on the grounds that Nancy's abortion, although not "necessary to perserve the life" of the patient, "was performed by a licensed physician in a medically accepted manner under medically accepted conditions," and therefore Michigan could not validly have prohibited it "in terms of its interest in maternal health." Nancy's case was similar to Margaret Smith's case. Each woman had been approximately 18 weeks pregnant, each had traveled to another state to undergo an abortion in an outpatient medical facility at the hands of a licensed physician, each had undergone a procedure to extract the fetus vaginally, and each had bled to death at the facility as a result of lacerations of their internal organs. But Margaret's abortion had been legal, and Ketchum no doubt calculated that if criminal abortion death convictions could be thrown out, a legal abortion death was no cause for concern. He petitioned the courts for his case to be dismissed and contined to perform abortions.  
+
Even convictions for criminal abortion deaths were being thrown out -- [[Richard Mucie]], for example, was able to have his conviction for the February 1968 abortion death of Nancy Ward in [[Missouri]] overturned on the grounds that Nancy's abortion, although not "necessary to preserve the life" of the patient, "was performed by a licensed physician in a medically accepted manner under medically accepted conditions," and therefore Michigan could not validly have prohibited it "in terms of its interest in maternal health." Nancy's case was similar to Margaret Smith's case. Each woman had been approximately 18 weeks pregnant, each had traveled to another state to undergo an abortion in an outpatient medical facility at the hands of a licensed physician, each had undergone a procedure to extract the fetus vaginally, and each had bled to death at the facility as a result of lacerations of internal organs. But Margaret's abortion had been legal, and Ketchum no doubt calculated that if criminal abortion death convictions could be thrown out, a legal abortion death was no cause for concern. He petitioned the courts for his case to be dismissed and continued to perform abortions.
 +
 
 +
Eventually, however, Ketchum was charged with [[homicide]] in Margaret Smith's death. When [[Roe v. Wade]] was handed down and assorted criminal abortionists started getting their old convictions thrown out, Ketchum tried to use ''Roe'' to get the charge against him dropped, and then to gain an acquittal. He got nowhere. Despite his claims that Margaret Smith had died from [[amniotic fluid embolism]] and [[disseminated intravascular coagulopathy]], and despite the fact that famed abortionist [[Milan Vuitch]] testified on his behalf, he was convicted of criminally negligent homicide and sentenced to prison on October 4, 1973.<ref>W.D. New York District Court No. Civ-75-79</ref>
 +
 
 +
But even a conviction was not enough to close Ketchum's practice. Still using ''Roe'' as leverage, Ketchum was able to free himself on $10,000 bond, pending appeal. He returned to Michigan and resumed his abortion practice there, this time legally. He remained heedless of the welfare of his patients, however. On April 18, 1974, Sandra Walker of Ohio was driven to Ketchum's practice by Thomas Pimbly, who had referred Sandra for the abortion. Pimbly assisted Ketchum in performing the outpatient [[saline abortion | saline instillation]], done without so much as a rudimentary physical examination. Sandra was hospitalized, losing a lot of blood, her uterus, and very nearly losing her life. Pimbly admitted that he'd known about Ketchum's background and that he referred women to him anyway. He said that 2 deaths in over 800 abortions was "a damn good batting average for a doctor, any doctor, and it's a batting average to be proud of." He continued to defend Ketchum, saying, "I'm not saying he's flawless. In fact, he's very controversial. If you've done any study, you know that his background is quite, quite good -- so good that other doctors refer problem patients to him for abortions."
 +
 
 +
Michigan prosecutors did not think so highly of Ketchum, and one filed suit alleging "gross negligence tantamount to criminal care of patients," and stating that Ketchum performed abortions "at times and in manners and places contrary to law," and in violation of state health guidelines, with inadequately qualified staff, lack of medical histories, and failure to maintain proper records. On April 30, a judge granted a court order banning Ketchum from practicing in Michigan. However, within a week another judge lifted the injunction, holding that the medical board, not the courts, should address the problem.
 +
 
 +
The deaths of two women and the near-deaths of at least two others were not sufficient to close down Jesse Ketchum's abortion practice. However, in 1974, his recklessness finally led him to behaviors that the medical board frowned upon. On May 12, Ketchum was found guilty of disorderly conduct for "indecent and obscene conduct in a public place," in this case a porn theater. Then, on May 23, Ketchum performed an abortion on a woman who then discovered that her pregnancy test had been negative. And on June 3, Ketchum was caught in a sting set up by a housewife who had heard he'd been doing abortions on women who only thought that they were pregnant. Last but not least, he was discovered to have been prescribing amphetamines after his state license to dispense these drugs had expired. These events, not the deaths and near-deaths, spurred the medical board to action. They suspended Ketchum's license for "unprofessional conduct, immoral conduct and departure from and failure to conform to minimal standards." His license was revoked in Michigan on October 30, 1974.
   −
Eventually, however, Ketchum was charged with [[homicide]] in Margaret Smith's death. When [[Roe v. Wade]] was handed down and assorted criminal abortionists started getting their old convictions thrown out, Ketchum tried Roe for leverage. He got nowhere. Eventually, he was sentenced to prison.<ref>W.D. New York District Court No. Civ-75-79</ref>
+
In May of 1975, Ketchum's appeals ran out, and he was sent to Attica for three years for the death of Margaret Smith. And in October of that year, the Centers for Disease control finally published an article with the New York Health Department suggesting that second trimester abortions should be done in hospitals.
   −
Prison did to Ketchum what lawsuits could not do -- it got him to give up his abortion practice.
+
After his release, Ketchum got his license reinstated. It is unknown whether he is still in practice.
    
==References==
 
==References==
Upload, Automoderated users, edit
101

edits