Changes

3,467 bytes added ,  13:30, March 6, 2007
no edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:  
[[Image:X_mark.jpg|thumb|200px|right]]
 
[[Image:X_mark.jpg|thumb|200px|right]]
   −
: ''This article is adapted from an article on [[CreationWiki]]. The content is under the GNU Free Documentation License.''--[[User:TerryH|TerryH]] 23:31, 5 March 2007 (EST)
+
A '''Logical fallacy''' is any argument that suffers from a crippling logical flaw.
   −
A '''Logical fallacy''' is an argument which violates the laws of logic.
+
Formal [[logic]] is a demanding discipline. Conclusions either follow from certain previously stated premises, or they do not. This is not, however, to say that a conclusion is always false if the argument supporting it is invalid. For example:
   −
==Some Fallacies==
+
#All undergraduates are human.
 +
#All sophomores are human.
 +
#Therefore, all sophomores are undergraduates.
 +
 
 +
One could as easily argue that all undergraduates are also sophomores, and the argument would be equally valid--or invalid in this case. However, one can establish the truth of the conclusion in another way--in this case, by [[definition]].
 +
 
 +
Logical fallacy ''is not'' the same as lying. A ''lie'' in logic is a premise that one offers, that the one offering the premise knows is false. False premises can still be part of valid arguments, but conclusions having false premises to support them will be unreliable. A logical fallacy, then, is a flawed argumental structure, one that would lead to an unreliable conclusion even when its premises are true.
 +
 
 +
The following is a catalog of logical fallacies, with each one given a separate heading, to make them easier to cite in other articles.
 +
 
 +
==Catalog of Logical Fallacies==
 
<table style="border:1px solid #AAAAAA; background: #EDF1F1; float:right; width:100px; margin-left:15px;">
 
<table style="border:1px solid #AAAAAA; background: #EDF1F1; float:right; width:100px; margin-left:15px;">
 
<tr><td>{{fallacy|type}}
 
<tr><td>{{fallacy|type}}
 
<tr><td>Use the <nowiki>{{fallacy|type}}</nowiki> template to insert the above warning on a page containing a ''logical fallacy''. Replace the word "type" with the name of the fallacy to link the warning label to the appropriate page.
 
<tr><td>Use the <nowiki>{{fallacy|type}}</nowiki> template to insert the above warning on a page containing a ''logical fallacy''. Replace the word "type" with the name of the fallacy to link the warning label to the appropriate page.
 
</table>
 
</table>
−
====Ad hominem====
+
====Argumentum ad hominem====
−
(Latin: "To the Man"); An argument which attacks people holding a contrary view, rather than attacking their view. ''Name-calling'' is a particularly crude form of this fallacy.
+
(Latin: "Argument directed toward the man"); An argument that attacks the character of one holding a contrary view, rather than attacking the view itself. ''Name-calling'' is a particularly crude form of this fallacy. ''Argumentum ad hominem'' is usually an attempt to accuse the other person of lying without saying so directly, or saying that his premises are somehow incompetent, irrelevant, or immaterial, or simply unreliable because they are self-serving. However, this is not good logic. If one suspects another of lying, then one should attempt to disprove the premises. One can raise a ''suspicion'' of deliberate falsehood on the part of another who has offered deliberate falsehood in the past. But the most that that can accomplish is to suggest that the other person's premises are unreliable and therefore require third-party corroboration.
 
    
 
    
 
====Overgeneralization====
 
====Overgeneralization====
−
An argument which makes a statement so broad as to be ridiculous.
+
An argument that attempts to apply a principle to circumstances beyond the scope of its original formulation or of any reliable demonstration. The application of [[Isaac Newton]]'s original theory of relative velocity (which is that it was simply additive) to speeds approaching that of light was an overgeneralization, as [[Albert Einstein]] would later show.
    
====Non sequitur====
 
====Non sequitur====
Line 73: Line 83:     
[[Special pleading]] means applying to other people a set of standards that one is not willing to apply to oneself, without offering any reasonable grounds for claiming such exemption. [[Jesus Christ]], of course, had a word for this sort of behavior: [[hypocrisy]].
 
[[Special pleading]] means applying to other people a set of standards that one is not willing to apply to oneself, without offering any reasonable grounds for claiming such exemption. [[Jesus Christ]], of course, had a word for this sort of behavior: [[hypocrisy]].
 +
 +
== Logical fallacy and the educational establishment ==
 +
Today, logic is offered as an elective in [[college]], not as a requirement. Various graduate-school admissions councils (among them the [http://www.mba.com/ Graduate Management Admissions Council] and the [http://www.lsac.org/ Law School Admissions Council]) have long recognized this fact and today test specifically for an appplicant's ability to [[Critical thinking|think critically]] and apply logic.
 +
 +
Thus the major admissions tests (Graduate Management Admission Test and Law School Admissions Test) feature questions on logical reasoning. A typical question would present an argument and ask either:
 +
 +
# What the argument assumes,
 +
# What sort of evidence, if established, would significantly strengthen (or weaken) the argument, or
 +
# Why the argument, as presented, is flawed.
 +
 +
Many of the arguments presented (the ''stimuli'') and the wrong answer choices offered illustrate classic logical fallacies, often strikingly. Examples of ''argumentum ad hominem'' and the closely related fallacy of ''non sequitur'', to name two key errors, abound in these questions.
 +
 +
Yet for all this effort in trying to identify weaknesses in critical thinking, colleges tend to discourage critical thinking in other ways, mainly in that [[professor]]s often commit the very sort of logical fallacies that these tests, for example, challenge their test-takers with.
    
== Related References ==
 
== Related References ==
 +
*[http://creationwiki.org/Logical_fallacy Logical fallacy] by [[CreationWiki]]
 
*[http://www.creationsafaris.com/crevbd.htm The Baloney Detector]
 
*[http://www.creationsafaris.com/crevbd.htm The Baloney Detector]
  
12,071

edits