Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 75: Line 75:  
::::Finally, homosexuals live a miserable life not due to oppression, but due to the fact that their behavior is immoral and unhealthy. There's ample of evidence on this website regarding that. - [[User:Markman|Markman]] 09:01, 24 February 2013 (EST)
 
::::Finally, homosexuals live a miserable life not due to oppression, but due to the fact that their behavior is immoral and unhealthy. There's ample of evidence on this website regarding that. - [[User:Markman|Markman]] 09:01, 24 February 2013 (EST)
   −
:::::It's still a slippery slope fallacy, Markman. If your example is inherently ''logical'', then the next statement is just as logical: "If we adopt the logic that it's OK for a man and a woman to have sex with each other so long as it's consensual, why not say that it's OK for a brother and a sister or mother and her son to have sex so long as it's consensual?"
+
:::::It's still a slippery slope fallacy, Markman. If your example is inherently ''logical'', then the next statement is just as logical: "If we adopt the logic that it's OK for a man and a woman to have sex with each other so long as it's consensual, why not say that it's OK for a brother and a sister or mother and her son to have sex so long as it's consensual?" Or: "If we adopt the logic that is okay to criminalize homosexuality, why not say that it's okay to punish homosexual acts with the death penalty?" Using that kind of logic everything can be "proven".
    
:::::You are right that Jefferson's proposal was not exactly gay friendly, but it should be added that he intended to ''liberalize'' the sodomy laws in Virginia at that time, which prescribed death as the maximum penalty for the crime of sodomy.
 
:::::You are right that Jefferson's proposal was not exactly gay friendly, but it should be added that he intended to ''liberalize'' the sodomy laws in Virginia at that time, which prescribed death as the maximum penalty for the crime of sodomy.
71

edits

Navigation menu