Judge [[Kenneth Ripple]], who had been appointed by President [[Ronald Reagan]], wrote the opinion for the 2-1 [[Seventh Circuit]]. Judge [[Diane Wood]], who was appointed by President [[Bill Clinton]], dissented. | Judge [[Kenneth Ripple]], who had been appointed by President [[Ronald Reagan]], wrote the opinion for the 2-1 [[Seventh Circuit]]. Judge [[Diane Wood]], who was appointed by President [[Bill Clinton]], dissented. |