Changes

Line 89: Line 89:     
::: I wasn't offended by your "observation", but found it to be inexplicably bizarre.  I articulated the postulate, then you replaced it with a far more complex and non-historical substitute, and then I simplified it into something clearer.  Your response was a petulant accusation, without even addressing the substance my improvement.  Are you saying the more concise, clearer formulation is wrong?  I can't even tell what your view is.--[[User:Aschlafly|Andy Schlafly]] 15:42, 21 April 2009 (EDT)
 
::: I wasn't offended by your "observation", but found it to be inexplicably bizarre.  I articulated the postulate, then you replaced it with a far more complex and non-historical substitute, and then I simplified it into something clearer.  Your response was a petulant accusation, without even addressing the substance my improvement.  Are you saying the more concise, clearer formulation is wrong?  I can't even tell what your view is.--[[User:Aschlafly|Andy Schlafly]] 15:42, 21 April 2009 (EDT)
 +
 +
:::: Until now, there were the history of the formulations of the postulate in the lecture reads like:
 +
::::# the speed of light never changes (original by Aschlafly)
 +
::::# the speed is the same for all observers (no matter what their relative speeds) (Clement B.)
 +
::::# the speed of light never changes (reversion by BHarlan)
 +
::::# the speed of light is independent of the motion of the light source (Pauli's version inserted by Clement B.)
 +
::::# the speed can never be increased (second version of Aschlafly)
 +
 +
::::Your formulations are shorter, but neither more concise or clearer. Furthermore, I don't know how you can label W. Pauli's version as non-historical?
 +
::::In his article  ''Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Koerper'' - ''About the electrodynamics of moving bodies''  (Annalen der Physik, 1905, p 891), Einstein wrote
 +
:::::'' 1. Die Gesetze, nach denen sich die Zustände der physikalischen Systeme ändern, sind unabhängig davon, auf welches von zwei relativ zueinander in gleichförmiger Translationsbewegung befindlichen Koordinatensystemen diese Zustandsänderungen bezogen werden.''
 +
 +
:::::''2. Jeder Lichtstrahl bewegt sich im ,,ruhenden“ Koordinatensystem mit der bestimmten Geschwindigkeit V , unabhängig davon, ob dieser Lichtstrahl von einem ruhenden oder bewegten Körper emittiert ist.  ''
 +
 +
::::This would be the historic origin of the postulates. A translation:
 +
 +
:::::''1. The laws which describe the change of the properties of physical systems are independent of a steady translation of the coordinates in which this changes are described''
 +
 +
:::::''2. Any ray of light moves in  «stationary» coordinates with a certain velocity V, regardless whether this ray was emitted from a stationary or moving body''
 +
 +
::::So, from the very beginning you find the same idea which Pauli describes concisely and clearly : '''the speed of light is independent of the motion of the light source'''
 +
 +
::::[[User:ClementB|Clement ♗]] 16:18, 21 April 2009 (EDT)
178

edits