Changes

22 bytes removed ,  03:14, January 10, 2011
Line 11: Line 11:  
On September 20, 2010, they filed a lawsuit alleging fifteen separate counts by reason of which the ObamaCare act is unconstitutional.<ref name=complaint>{{cite web|last=Hurlbut|first=Terry|authorlink=User:TerryH|url=http://www.examiner.com/essex-county-conservative-in-newark/jersey-shore-tea-party-files-pro-se-complaint-against-feds-re-healthcare|title=Jersey Shore Tea Party files pro se complaint against feds re healthcare|publisher=Essex County Conservative Examiner|date=2010-09-28|accessmonthday=January 9|accessyear=2011}}</ref> Specifically:
 
On September 20, 2010, they filed a lawsuit alleging fifteen separate counts by reason of which the ObamaCare act is unconstitutional.<ref name=complaint>{{cite web|last=Hurlbut|first=Terry|authorlink=User:TerryH|url=http://www.examiner.com/essex-county-conservative-in-newark/jersey-shore-tea-party-files-pro-se-complaint-against-feds-re-healthcare|title=Jersey Shore Tea Party files pro se complaint against feds re healthcare|publisher=Essex County Conservative Examiner|date=2010-09-28|accessmonthday=January 9|accessyear=2011}}</ref> Specifically:
   −
# The Act, HR 3590, originated in the [[United States Senate]] and not the [[United States House of Representatives]]. Yet it is clearly a revenue-raising bill, because it includes various tax and penalty provisions. This violates Article I, Section 7, Paragraph 1, which reads in relevant part:{{cquote|All bills for raising revenue shall originate in the House of Representatives.}}
+
# The Act, HR 3590, originated in the [[United States Senate]] and not the [[United States House of Representatives]]. Yet it is clearly a revenue-raising bill, because it includes various tax and penalty provisions. This violates Article I, Section 7, Paragraph 1, which requires that "all bills for raising revenue...originate in the House of Representatives."
 
# The Act features a "minimum coverage mandate" that forces individuals, businesses, and other groups, on pain of various fines, to purchase health-care insurance with a mimimum level of coverage that in many cases far exceeds what these individuals, businesses, and groups are prepared to pay for. The government has no authority so to act, even under the Commerce Clause (Article I, Section 8, Clause 3).
 
# The Act features a "minimum coverage mandate" that forces individuals, businesses, and other groups, on pain of various fines, to purchase health-care insurance with a mimimum level of coverage that in many cases far exceeds what these individuals, businesses, and groups are prepared to pay for. The government has no authority so to act, even under the Commerce Clause (Article I, Section 8, Clause 3).
 
# The Act creates what would become an eighth uniformed service of the United States (in addition to the [[United States Army]], [[United States Navy|Navy]], [[United States Marine Corps|Marines]], [[United States Air Force|Air Force]], [[United States Coast Guard|Coast Guard]], [[United States Public Health Service Corps]] (the service that the [[Surgeon General of the United States]] commands), and the uniformed research service of the [[National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration]]. Because this new service would be an army (and in fact would be called the National Healthcare Army), it is not supposed to receive an appropriation for any period greater than two years (I.8.12). HR 3590 provides a four-year appropriation.
 
# The Act creates what would become an eighth uniformed service of the United States (in addition to the [[United States Army]], [[United States Navy|Navy]], [[United States Marine Corps|Marines]], [[United States Air Force|Air Force]], [[United States Coast Guard|Coast Guard]], [[United States Public Health Service Corps]] (the service that the [[Surgeon General of the United States]] commands), and the uniformed research service of the [[National Oceanographic and Atmospheric Administration]]. Because this new service would be an army (and in fact would be called the National Healthcare Army), it is not supposed to receive an appropriation for any period greater than two years (I.8.12). HR 3590 provides a four-year appropriation.
12,071

edits