Block, SkipCaptcha, Automoderated users, edit, rollback
1,924
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 88:
Line 88: + + + + + + + +
→Netball redux: new section
:::Professor, please don't use words like 'lie' in such a cavalier fashion. I don't doubt that your additions were factual, but the presentation of facts matters a great deal, especially with such a controversial topic. Any discussion of evolutionary ideas must present both sides of the argument - your evolutionary additions are welcome, but the article as you left it was hopelessly biased towards the evolutionary side. No doubt your points can be added to the article, but each put in its proper context and discussed objectively. [[User:Jcw|Jcw]] 19:45, 29 June 2011 (EDT)
:::Professor, please don't use words like 'lie' in such a cavalier fashion. I don't doubt that your additions were factual, but the presentation of facts matters a great deal, especially with such a controversial topic. Any discussion of evolutionary ideas must present both sides of the argument - your evolutionary additions are welcome, but the article as you left it was hopelessly biased towards the evolutionary side. No doubt your points can be added to the article, but each put in its proper context and discussed objectively. [[User:Jcw|Jcw]] 19:45, 29 June 2011 (EDT)
== Netball redux ==
First, I get the gin part, but dead birds? Do I even want to ask?
Second, I would appreciate it if someone higher than me here at CP would look at the [[Bias in Wikipedia]] entry for netball and gender bias. The part about the editor getting banned for his edits isn't true. He got banned for harassment and for reporting the main author of the WP netball article to her supposed real-life employer. Given the name of the person who added the entry to the CP bias article and who wrote the CP netball article (they used the name of an editor who actually was a supporter of the main author), I suspect either the banned editor or one of his friends couldn't let it go. They made sure to use one of the main author's edits, which then shows her name in the CP references.
I don't like sneaky nasty tricks and this one definitely has the feel of one to me. Thanks! [[User:SharonW|SharonW]] 10:35, 1 July 2011 (EDT)