Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
better
Line 11: Line 11:  
We'll know the answer on the night of Election Day, in only about two weeks!
 
We'll know the answer on the night of Election Day, in only about two weeks!
   −
== Independent Agencies ==
+
Monday night, October 22, at 9pm, is the final presidential debate for 2012.  Because the polls show that the candidates are nearly tied, many are observing that the performance in this debate may decide the outcome of the election.
   −
Two of the agencies discussed in the homework (week 4) are independent agencies:  the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Federal Election Commission (FEC).  Additional examples of an independent agency are the Social Security Administration (SSA) and the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).
+
Indeed, it appears that debates have had more influence over this presidential race than almost any other in history.  There were numerous presidential debates during the Republican primary, and that apparently helped Mitt Romney improve his debating skills because he then defeated Barack Obama by the widest recorded margin (according to public opinion polls) in their first debate in Denver.  But Obama recovered and narrowly defeated Romney in their second debate, which used a town hall format that favored Obama's more likable style.  This third debate Monday night, in Florida, returns to the more formal format of the first debate, which seemed to favor Romney's style.
−
 
  −
So what is an "independent" agency? It is an agency that is outside the direct control of the president, and not part of any Executive Branch Department that reports to the president.
  −
 
  −
The purpose behind independent agencies that they be outside the political influence of a president, or a presidential election.  Some students pointed out how important that is for the Federal Election Commission.  But a counterargument is this:  to whom are these agencies accountable, if not to the American people who vote in elections??  Having independent agencies may, unfortunately, mean independence from public accountability.  The NLRB, for example, can side with unions more than the American people want, and not even winning a presidential election can necessarily change that.  Fortunately, the president does have the power to appoint new members to run these agencies.
     −
The most controversial of all independent agencies is the "Federal Reserve," which is the central bank for the United States.  It possesses enormous power over the economy and yet is accountable to almost no one.  Congressman Ron Paul, a presidential candidate in 2008 and again in 2012, has urged passage of a law requiring audits of the financial books of the Federal Reserve (called the "Fed" for short) for the American people to see and scrutinize.  Though gaining support on both sides of the political spectrum, it has not passed and the Federal Reserve continues to operate with almost no outside knowledge of what it is really doing.
+
In tennis, the surface on which the game is played (grass, clay or concrete) gives an advantage to one player or the other.  Likewise in politics:  the format of a debate will tend to favor the style of one candidate or his opponent, and who does better in a debate has some impact on who wins an election.  There are, of course, many other factors, such as which powerful "interest groups" endorse a candidate.
    
== Interest groups ==
 
== Interest groups ==
Line 157: Line 153:     
Often polls will be used to portray a candidate as a “winner” to the public.  Some voters like to back someone they think will win, simply to be in the winning side.  This is a bigger problem in foreign countries like England, where “underdogs” are unpopular.  It is a factor in the United States with respect to raising money, because popularity in polls makes it easier to raise campaign money.  So candidates will employ their own pollsters to generate as positive data as possible about their candidate.
 
Often polls will be used to portray a candidate as a “winner” to the public.  Some voters like to back someone they think will win, simply to be in the winning side.  This is a bigger problem in foreign countries like England, where “underdogs” are unpopular.  It is a factor in the United States with respect to raising money, because popularity in polls makes it easier to raise campaign money.  So candidates will employ their own pollsters to generate as positive data as possible about their candidate.
 +
 +
 +
 +
== Demographics and politics ==
 +
 +
<use the following questions w/ answers>
 +
. The fastest growing age group of voters in America is: (a) under 18; (b) between 18 and 35; (c) over 65; (d) over 100. What is the significance of this demographic fact?
 +
5. The best single predictor of how a group votes on Election Day is _____________. Explain.
 +
6. Children argue with their parents about politics, but usually vote as they did. E.g., children of Democrats usually become Democrats themselves. Why?
 +
7. Design a two-question poll about the death penalty that is slanted in order to maximize a response against the death penalty. Then design poll questions about the death penalty slanted in order to maximize support for it.
 +
8. The most reliable poll about the political prospects of the president and his party is his “approval rating." Why is this poll more reliable than most polls?
 +
9. Do polls have too much influence in American politics, or do they have a valuable role? Explain with an example.
 +
    
'''V. The Political Spectrum'''
 
'''V. The Political Spectrum'''
Line 193: Line 202:     
This regional split makes it very difficult for either party to grab control of the federal government.  It ensures divided government for many years to come.
 
This regional split makes it very difficult for either party to grab control of the federal government.  It ensures divided government for many years to come.
 +
 +
== Review: Independent Agencies ==
 +
 +
Two of the agencies discussed in the homework (week 4) are independent agencies:  the Federal Communications Commission (FCC) and the Federal Election Commission (FEC).  Additional examples of an independent agency are the Social Security Administration (SSA) and the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB).
 +
 +
So what is an "independent" agency?  It is an agency that is outside the direct control of the president, and not part of any Executive Branch Department that reports to the president.
 +
 +
The purpose behind independent agencies that they be outside the political influence of a president, or a presidential election.  Some students pointed out how important that is for the Federal Election Commission.  But a counterargument is this:  to whom are these agencies accountable, if not to the American people who vote in elections??  Having independent agencies may, unfortunately, mean independence from public accountability.  The NLRB, for example, can side with unions more than the American people want, and not even winning a presidential election can necessarily change that.  Fortunately, the president does have the power to appoint new members to run these agencies.
 +
 +
The most controversial of all independent agencies is the "Federal Reserve," which is the central bank for the United States.  It possesses enormous power over the economy and yet is accountable to almost no one.  Congressman Ron Paul, a presidential candidate in 2008 and again in 2012, has urged passage of a law requiring audits of the financial books of the Federal Reserve (called the "Fed" for short) for the American people to see and scrutinize.  Though gaining support on both sides of the political spectrum, it has not passed and the Federal Reserve continues to operate with almost no outside knowledge of what it is really doing.
    
== Homework ==
 
== Homework ==
Anthony, Irenaeus, Siteadmin, apieditor, Bureaucrats, Check users, nsAm_Govt_101RO, nsAm_Govt_101RW, nsAm_Govt_101_ta, nsJudgesRO, nsJudgesRW, nsJudges_talkRO, nsJudges_talkRW, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, oversight, Administrators
126,764

edits

Navigation menu