Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 117: Line 117:     
What do you think about third parties?
 
What do you think about third parties?
−
  −
'''II. What is a Poll?'''
  −
  −
A poll is simply a measure of the view of a group of people.  I could take a poll of the opinion of this class.  That would be cheap and quick.  Or I could take a poll of what people in my town think about something.  That would take more time and money.
  −
  −
Would I have to ask everyone single person in my town in order to estimate its views?  Finding and talking to every single person would improve the accuracy of my poll.  But even that would not be 100% accurate, become people might change their mind or fail to tell me, a stranger, what they really think.
  −
  −
If I only need an estimate, and can live with the possible of a small error, then I do not have to ask every single person.  On a political issue, I could obtain a good picture of my town’s view by asking a random group of 40 Democrats, 40 Republicans and 40 Independents.  That is only 120 people in all.  I could call them over a three day period.
  −
  −
That is all that most political pollsters do.  For nationwide polls, the group running the poll will only call a thousand or so persons.  This is called “random sampling.”  The sample is carefully selected, however, to make sure it represents the nation as a whole.  For example, there should be the same percentage of union workers in the sample as in the nation at large.  There should be the same percentage of religiously devout people in the same as in the nation.
  −
  −
In predicting elections, the most difficult part is finding a sample that represents people who will actually vote on Election Day.  Half or more of eligible Americans do not typically vote.  If you call someone at random, the odds are 50/50 or worse that you are talking to someone who does not vote.  His or her opinion is irrelevant.  It should not be included in a political poll.  The lower the turnout – e.g., the higher the percentage of those who do not vote – the more difficult it is for a poll to predict the outcome of an election.
  −
  −
Query: which can polls predict better, general elections or primaries?  (Answer: general elections, because they have higher turnout.)
  −
  −
In “straw polls” that invite the public to contact the pollster, as on the Internet and American Idol, there is no control over the sample.  The people who take the initiative to give their opinion to the pollster are not representative of those who do not.  Also, multiple voting by the same person can occur.  These are unreliable polls.
  −
  −
Polls are constantly improving how they select their samples, but can never choose a perfect sample.  If you are interested in math, then you may want to look for books and articles on this topic.
  −
  −
'''III. How Polls are Manipulated'''
  −
  −
Poll results are easily manipulated by distorting how the questions are asked.  In a poll on gun control, the question “Do you support gun control?” will obtain more “yes” answers than the corresponding “no” answers to “Do you have a right to own a gun?”  So gun control proponents will ask the first question in their polls, while gun rights proponents will ask the second question in their polls.  Both will claim that the public supports their view.
  −
  −
Ordering of questions will also change the answers.  Ask the question “Do you think convicts should own guns?” before asking a question about gun control, and you will increase a response in favor of gun control.  In contrast, ask the question “Do you think people should be able to own guns to protect themselves?” before asking a question about gun control will decrease the response in favor of gun control.
  −
  −
All political issues are affected by how the question is asked.  Many states, including California, Texas and New Jersey, have procedures for putting issues on the ballots for voters.  Every time there is a struggle over how the question is worded.  A slight change in style can mean the difference between its passage or rejection, even though the substance does not change.
  −
  −
Recently supporters of gay marriage published a poll claiming that most people favored it.  This was in spite of the fact that every time the issue has been put to voters, gay marriage has been defeated.  The trick to the poll?  It used a word that has an ambiguous meaning: “sanction”.  “Sanction” can mean either to endorse something, or to penalize it.  The poll asked whether gay marriage should be “sanctioned”.  The confusion created was probably intentional.  Always check the wording of polls to see if they are clear and unambiguous.
  −
  −
Another trick in manipulating polls is to ask a general question rather than a specific one.  “Do you support equal rights for women?” is likely to generate a favorable response.  However, voters repeatedly defeated referenda for the “Equal Rights Amendment,” which would impose burdens like the military draft on women.  An indication of whether people support the Equal Rights Amendment would be to ask the question: “Do you support drafting women into combat?”  That is not likely to generate a favorable response.
  −
  −
Before interpreting a poll, always look at the details of the questions that are asked.
  −
  −
'''IV. Unavoidable Flaws in Polls'''
  −
  −
While some of the flaws in polls are due to manipulation, other flaws are unavoidable but are often ignored.  What are some examples?
  −
  −
Polls only capture public opinion at a given time.  They are typically useless in predicting opinion in the future.
  −
  −
At one time the people wanted to make Jesus Christ their king, and then a few weeks later the people wanted to crucify him. And Jesus knew that would happen.
  −
  −
President Reagan never had very high approval ratings as president.  Yet his approval rating when he left office after his second term was higher than any other president on his last day of office.  Sometimes what is unpopular at one given time becomes more popular later.  An unpopular teacher may be one who assigns a lot of homework.  However, he may become very popular later when students do well based on what they learned!
  −
  −
The first President Bush broke records for high approval ratings during the Gulf War in 1991.  Yet by Election Day in 1992, his approval rating was very low and he was defeated by a wide margin by President Clinton.
  −
  −
Increasing government spending can be popular at first, because voters receive additional monies from the government.  But as the effects of a larger deficit are felt, unpopularity can set in.
  −
  −
In the eyes of the public, a person can be a hero today but a goat tomorrow.  Reading public opinion polls requires anticipating how the public will feel in the future.  That is very difficult, often impossible, to do.
  −
  −
Polls also fail to capture the strength of people’s support.  A “yes” or “no” answer to an opinion question does not reveal how strongly one feels about their answer.  A “yes, but I don’t really care much” is very different from a “yes, and I’ll volunteer my time to make sure this happens.”  Many politicians have been fooled by public opinion polls about abortion.  Many against abortion are willing to volunteer their time and effort to stop it, and often vote on that issue alone.  But many of those who accept abortion do not vote based on that issue.
  −
  −
It is not only the opinion of the public that matters in political races.  The opinion of the media is also very influential.  The media is pro-abortion, and will give less favorable treatment to a candidate who is pro-life.
  −
  −
Often polls will be used to portray a candidate as a “winner” to the public.  Some voters like to back someone they think will win, simply to be in the winning side.  This is a bigger problem in foreign countries like England, where “underdogs” are unpopular.  It is a factor in the United States with respect to raising money, because popularity in polls makes it easier to raise campaign money.  So candidates will employ their own pollsters to generate as positive data as possible about their candidate.
      
== Demographics and politics ==
 
== Demographics and politics ==
Anthony, Irenaeus, Siteadmin, apieditor, Bureaucrats, Check users, nsAm_Govt_101RO, nsAm_Govt_101RW, nsAm_Govt_101_ta, nsJudgesRO, nsJudgesRW, nsJudges_talkRO, nsJudges_talkRW, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, oversight, Administrators
126,764

edits

Navigation menu