| Line 109: |
Line 109: |
| | The spectrum of different types of markets looks like this: | | The spectrum of different types of markets looks like this: |
| | | | |
| − | # Monopoly (MC=MR is how the price is determined) | + | # Monopoly |
| | # Cartel | | # Cartel |
| | # Oligopoly | | # Oligopoly |
| | # Monopolistic Competition | | # Monopolistic Competition |
| | # Perfectly Contestable Markets | | # Perfectly Contestable Markets |
| − | # Perfect Competition (MC=MR at a lower point P, where P=ATC) | + | # Perfect Competition |
| | | | |
| − | As a seller, you make more money the higher you are on the list. As a buyer, you save more money the lower you are the list. Let’s have a brief overview of each, and them review them in greater detail. On an exam, it is most important that you understand the differences between each type:
| + | For all of the above, the selling price P is determined by when MC=MR, but he higher in the list, the higher that price P will be. The lowest P occurs for perfect competition, for which P=ATC. |
| | + | |
| | + | Let’s review each type of market next: |
| | | | |
| | ===Monopoly=== | | ===Monopoly=== |
| − | A single seller of a product having no competition or close substitutes. The seller comprises the entire industry. | + | '''''A monopoly is a single seller of a product having no competition or close substitutes'''''. The seller comprises the entire industry. |
| | | | |
| − | A related concept is the “monopsony”, which is a “buyer’s monopoly.” It consists of a single buyer of a good or service. In a one-company isolated town, where one company employs most of the people, the company is nearly a monopsony with respect to labor in that town. Note that the more it hires, the greater its wage costs will become. But perfect monopsonies are difficult to imagine. Can you think of another one? | + | A related concept is the “monopsony”, which is a “buyer’s monopoly.” It consists of a single buyer of a good or service. In a one-company isolated town, where one company employs most of the people, the company is nearly a monopsony with respect to labor in that town. Notice that the more it hires, the greater its wage costs will become. But perfect monopsonies are difficult to imagine. Can you think of another one? |
| | | | |
| | ===Cartel=== | | ===Cartel=== |
| − | A group of producers that agree on fixing prices, restricting output, or allocating market share. OPEC, a group of mostly Arab oil producers attempting to keep profits high, is the most famous cartel. Cartels are illegal in the United States; they are prohibited here by American antitrust law. | + | '''''A cartel is a group of producers who agree on fixing prices, restricting output, or allocating market share'''''. OPEC, a group of mostly Arab oil producers attempting to keep profits high, is the most famous cartel. Cartels are illegal in the United States; they are prohibited here by American antitrust law. |
| | | | |
| | ===Oligopoly=== | | ===Oligopoly=== |
| − | A few producers that dominate a market without fixing prices or output. If the good is identical among the companies, then it is a perfect or pure oligopoly. Examples include the steel and cement industries. Cement is cement, period. If the good is not identical, then it is an imperfect oligopoly. Examples are the car or soap industries. Cars are not identical to each other, but the auto industry is an (imperfect) oligopoly.
| + | '''''An oligopoly is a few producers who dominate a market without fixing prices or output'''''. If the good is identical among the companies, then it is a perfect or pure oligopoly. Examples include the steel and cement industries. Cement is cement, period. If the good is not identical, then it is an imperfect oligopoly. Examples are the car or soap industries. Cars are not identical to each other, but the auto industry is an (imperfect) oligopoly. |
| | | | |
| | ===Monopolistic Competition=== | | ===Monopolistic Competition=== |
| − | This has more sellers than an oligopoly and more competition too. But companies are able to increase their prices without losing all their customers. Why? Because in monopolistic competition there are “differentiated products.” An example is the haircutting or hairdressing industry. Cutting hair is a service that is not a perfect substitute for other haircutting services. One with a loyal customer base can increase her prices without losing her business. | + | This has more sellers than an oligopoly and more competition too. But companies are able to increase their prices without losing all their customers. Why? Because '''''in monopolistic competition there are “differentiated products.”''''' An example is the haircutting or hairdressing industry. Cutting hair is a service that is not a perfect substitute for other haircutting services. One with a loyal customer base can increase her prices without losing all her customers. |
| | | | |
| | ===Perfectly Contestable Markets=== | | ===Perfectly Contestable Markets=== |
| − | This is where there is no barrier to entry into the market and no start-up costs. There are only a few sellers, or maybe only one seller, but competition is always threatened. A newspaper vendor in a shopping mall is an example. He may be the only one, but he does not have an monopoly because it is so easy for another competitor to start selling newspapers. This "perfect" threat of competition forces him always to keep his prices as low as he can. | + | This is where '''''there is no barrier to entry into the market and no start-up costs'''''. There are only a few sellers, or maybe only one seller, but competition is always threatened. A newspaper vendor in a shopping mall is an example. He may be the only one, but he does not have an monopoly because it is so easy for another competitor to start selling newspapers. This "perfect" threat of competition forces him always to keep his prices as low as he can. |
| | | | |
| | ===Perfect Competition=== | | ===Perfect Competition=== |
| − | A large number of sellers and buyers have full knowledge and perfect mobility of resources. The good or service is homogeneous. Competition is ruthless in keeping prices down. Price (P) equals Marginal Cost (MC) equals Average Total Cost (ATC). This is what happens when Wal-Mart moves in next door! | + | A large number of sellers and buyers have full knowledge and perfect mobility of resources. The good or service is homogeneous. Competition is ruthless in keeping prices down. '''''Price (P) equals Marginal Cost (MC) equals Average Total Cost (ATC)'''''. This is what happens when Wal-Mart moves in next door! |
| | | | |
| | Understand all the above concepts? We’ll review the most important ones now in greater detail. | | Understand all the above concepts? We’ll review the most important ones now in greater detail. |
| Line 142: |
Line 144: |
| | ==Oligopoly== | | ==Oligopoly== |
| | | | |
| − | Memorize these three conditions for an oligopoly market: (1) few companies, (2) high barriers to entry, and (3) similar goods. | + | Memorize these '''''three conditions for an oligopoly market: (1) few companies, (2) high barriers to entry, and (3) similar goods'''''. |
| | | | |
| | The car industry is a good example: General Motors, Ford, Toyota, and a handful of others. All the car companies in the world could be listed on one sheet of paper. So this satisfies the first condition: few companies. | | The car industry is a good example: General Motors, Ford, Toyota, and a handful of others. All the car companies in the world could be listed on one sheet of paper. So this satisfies the first condition: few companies. |
| Line 148: |
Line 150: |
| | Is there a high barrier to entry? Yes. It is not easy or cheap to start a new car company. There has not been a new American car company in decades. John DeLorean was the last one to try, and his effort went bankrupt. So condition two is satisfied. | | Is there a high barrier to entry? Yes. It is not easy or cheap to start a new car company. There has not been a new American car company in decades. John DeLorean was the last one to try, and his effort went bankrupt. So condition two is satisfied. |
| | | | |
| − | Are cars similar goods? Yes again. There are differences, of course, but they all have four wheels, an engine, and run on gas (or, now, electric rechargeable battery). They take you from point A to point B. When you need to drive somewhere, you usually do not care what type of car is available. Any one will typically do. So condition three is satisfied. | + | Are cars similar goods? Yes again. There are differences, of course, but they all have four wheels, an engine, and run on gas (or sometimes an electric rechargeable battery). They take you from point A to point B. When you need to drive somewhere, you usually do not care what type of car is available. Any one will typically do. So condition three is satisfied. |
| | | | |
| | Thus the car industry is an oligopoly. Can you think of other oligopolies? | | Thus the car industry is an oligopoly. Can you think of other oligopolies? |
| Line 160: |
Line 162: |
| | There are two models for what the demand curve looks like for an oligopoly. One famous model is the “kinked” demand curve. In this scenario, if one firm raises its price then the other firms do not have to imitate it. The firm that raises its price sees a sharp falloff in demand. The change in slope causes the “kink” in the curve. However, if a firm lowers its price, then the other firms must lower their price also to keep their customers. | | There are two models for what the demand curve looks like for an oligopoly. One famous model is the “kinked” demand curve. In this scenario, if one firm raises its price then the other firms do not have to imitate it. The firm that raises its price sees a sharp falloff in demand. The change in slope causes the “kink” in the curve. However, if a firm lowers its price, then the other firms must lower their price also to keep their customers. |
| | | | |
| − | The other model for an oligopoly is when there is a dominant firm that sets the price for the entire industry as the “price leader.” There can be many smaller firms or companies, but they follow the pricing of the dominant firm. If they don’t, then the powerful firm can "punish" them with price-cutting. If the demand is relatively inelastic, then the dominant firm sets a high and profitable price. The smaller companies must follow it in order to avoid being punished for underselling it. | + | The other model for an oligopoly is when there is a dominant firm that sets the price for the entire industry as the “price leader.” There can be many smaller firms or companies, but they follow the pricing of the dominant firm. If they don’t, then the powerful firm can “punish” them with price-cutting. If the demand is relatively inelastic, then the dominant firm sets a high and profitable price. The smaller companies must follow it in order to avoid being “punished” for underselling it. |
| | | | |
| | ===Game Theory and the Nash Equilibrium=== | | ===Game Theory and the Nash Equilibrium=== |
| Line 168: |
Line 170: |
| | His insight is called the [[Nash equilibrium]], which predicts an "equilibrium" set of pricing decisions by firms, where the market "settles down" to a stable price. | | His insight is called the [[Nash equilibrium]], which predicts an "equilibrium" set of pricing decisions by firms, where the market "settles down" to a stable price. |
| | | | |
| − | '''''The Nash equilibrium is this: the set of decisions such that no firm can improve its position assuming the other firms' decisions remain unchanged.''''' If a firm can improve its position, then it does so, and then check again to see if another firm can improve its position, and if it can then it changes also. Keep doing this until no firm can improve its position on its own, and then you've found the equilibrium (the Nash equilibrium). Group decisions are prohibited, just as oligopolies are prohibited by law from making decisions together. | + | '''''The Nash equilibrium occurs when no firm can improve its position by changing its decision, assuming the other firms' decisions remain unchanged.''''' If a firm can improve its position, then it does so, and then check again to see if another firm can improve its position. Keep doing this until no firm can improve its position on its own, and then you've found the equilibrium (the Nash equilibrium). Group decisions are prohibited, just as oligopolies are prohibited by law from making decisions together. |
| | + | |
| | + | A famous application of the Nash equilibrium is the "prisoner's dilemma," whereby two partners in crime are interrogated in separate rooms. In this "game" the best individual result is obtained by one criminal if he confesses but his partner does not, and the second best result is if neither confesses. But if neither confess then one criminal can improve his outcome by confessing and testifying against his partner, and then the other criminal can improve his result by also confessing. The Nash equilibrium predicts that the outcome moves to an "equilibrium" of both confessing. |
| | | | |
| − | A famous application of the Nash equilibrium is the "prisoner's dilemma," whereby two partners in crime are interrogated in separate rooms. In this "game" the best individual result is obtained by one criminal if he confesses but his partner does not, and the second best result is if neither confesses. But if neither confess then one criminal can improve his outcome by confessing and testifying against his partner, and then the other criminal can improve his result by also confessing. The Nash equilibrium predicts that the outcomes moves to an "equilibrium" of both confessing.
| + | Microeconomics exams usually have at least one question about the Nash equilibrium. Trial-and-error using the above bolded rule helps to solve it, and then check your answer by switching the rivals in the game (or firms in the market). The outcome should be the same no matter how you interchange the rivals, and '''''no one acting alone should be able to improve his reward at the equilibrium by changing his decision'''''. |
| | | | |
| − | This type of question may show up on the CLEP exam. First try to find the Nash equilibrium and then check your answer by switching the rivals in the game (or firms in the market). The outcome should be the same no matter how you interchange the rivals, and no one acting alone should be able to improve his reward at the equilibrium by changing his decision.
| + | '''''Example''''': two gas stations at an intersection. The Nash equilibrium for the pricce will not be higher than marginal cost, because if it were, then one of the two gas stations would lower its price slightly, and then the other gas station would also lower its price to avoid losing customers. Eventually the price for both stations is equal to their marginal revenue, and neither gas station can improve its profits by changing its price. |
| | | | |
| | ==Cartel== | | ==Cartel== |