Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
1,429 bytes added ,  05:30, November 29, 2014
no edit summary
Line 30: Line 30:     
PZ Myers wrote about bestiality:
 
PZ Myers wrote about bestiality:
−
{{cquote|So, to answer clueless thick-skulled Christian idiot’s question, I don’t object to [[Atheism and bestiality|bestiality]] in a very limited set of specific conditions, but do not support it in any way<ref name="achilles">[http://templestream.blogspot.com/2012/08/atheist-achilles-heels-objective.html Atheist Achilles Heels: Objective Morality and Sacred Life]</ref><ref>[http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2012/05/22/the-objective-morality-gotcha/ The “objective morality” gotcha]</ref>}}
+
{{cquote|So, to answer clueless thick-skulled Christian idiot’s question, I don’t object to [[Atheism and bestiality|bestiality]] in a very limited set of specific conditions, but do not support it in any way.<ref name="achilles">[http://templestream.blogspot.com/2012/08/atheist-achilles-heels-objective.html Atheist Achilles Heels: Objective Morality and Sacred Life]</ref><ref>[http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2012/05/22/the-objective-morality-gotcha/ The “objective morality” gotcha]</ref>}}
    
A Christian commented on Myers's statement:
 
A Christian commented on Myers's statement:
−
{{cquote| If you are sensing that there is something amiss with a person stating he neither supports nor opposes bestiality, then you are more perceptive with regard to moral reasoning than PZ Myers is. Myers once stated his morality is based on feelings of empathy. In an interview he stated, "If I punched you in the face, you would feel bad and I would feel bad ..and that's where morality comes from."  Ironically, Myers offers a cartoon that mocks plaintive logic, that is, logic based on feelings, which is exactly the same basis of morality Myers appealed to in his interview.
+
{{cquote|If you are sensing that there is something amiss with a person stating he neither supports nor opposes bestiality, then you are more perceptive with regard to moral reasoning than PZ Myers is. Myers once stated his morality is based on feelings of empathy. In an interview he stated, "If I punched you in the face, you would feel bad and I would feel bad ..and that's where morality comes from."  Ironically, Myers offers a cartoon that mocks plaintive logic, that is, logic based on feelings, which is exactly the same basis of morality Myers appealed to in his interview.
    
When I sent Myers an email asking him to clarify what "specific conditions" would make bestiality morally acceptable in his opinion, he declined to address my email and my second article on the subject. There is really only one likely scenario in which it seems Myers would accept bestiality, also known as zoophilia, and that is if it is apparent that the animal is not being harmed and if it is demonstrating some kind of approval, enjoyment or "consent" in the act. The problem for Myers here is quite simple. If nothing must be held sacred, then why should bestiality be considered acceptable only under certain conditions and not always? Why should animal rights be an issue if animal rights are not sacred? These are logical contradictions he needs to address. What is happening here is that Myers is revealing in his quote that he does in fact believe that some boundaries must be held sacred.<ref name="achilles" />}}
 
When I sent Myers an email asking him to clarify what "specific conditions" would make bestiality morally acceptable in his opinion, he declined to address my email and my second article on the subject. There is really only one likely scenario in which it seems Myers would accept bestiality, also known as zoophilia, and that is if it is apparent that the animal is not being harmed and if it is demonstrating some kind of approval, enjoyment or "consent" in the act. The problem for Myers here is quite simple. If nothing must be held sacred, then why should bestiality be considered acceptable only under certain conditions and not always? Why should animal rights be an issue if animal rights are not sacred? These are logical contradictions he needs to address. What is happening here is that Myers is revealing in his quote that he does in fact believe that some boundaries must be held sacred.<ref name="achilles" />}}
 +
 +
=== Atheist animal trainer objects to PZ Myers comments about bestiality ===
 +
 +
On May 22, 2012, PZ Myers specifies under what conditions he thinks the practice of bestiality would be acceptable.<ref>[http://freethoughtblogs.com/pharyngula/2012/05/22/the-objective-morality-gotcha/ The “objective morality” gotcha], PZ Myers, May 22, 2012</ref>
 +
 +
On November 14, 2014, an atheist animal trainer wrote in response:
 +
{{cquote|We now have the PZ Myers Humanist Guide to Bestiality:
 +
*1. IF you are interested in having sex with an animal, AND;
 +
*2. That animal is willing to have sex with you, AND;
 +
*3. No real harm comes to the animal, AND;
 +
*4. You can avoid social stigma by hiding your act;
 +
>> THEN sex with an animal is ethical...
 +
 +
PZ Myers possesses numerous character flaws that make him ill-suited as an A/S/humanism spokesperson and representative: his explosive temper; his violence-tinged threats; his foul language; his preference for personal insults over reasoned debate; his propensity to smear and slander any & all who oppose him;..his willingness to abandon skepticism and science to serve the pomo constructs of radical feminism and social justice warriordom.
 +
 +
Of all these, nothing is more odious, repulsive, or damaging to the reputation of A/S & humanist activism, than Myers’ condoning of bestiality.<ref>[http://skeptischism.com/atheismneat/2014/11/14/pz-myers-animal-lover/ PZ Myers, Animal Lover]</ref>}}
    
=== Michael Nugent's commentary on PZ Myers' material about human/octopus sexual relations ===
 
=== Michael Nugent's commentary on PZ Myers' material about human/octopus sexual relations ===
Irenaeus, Siteadmin, Check users, oversight, Administrators
352,181

edits

Navigation menu