Changes

'''Shifting the burden of proof''' is an effort to free [[hypothesis]] or persuasive [[argument]] in debate from [[burden of proof]] by shifting it onto opponent. The critic is deliberately placed in the position of trying to prove negative with respect to original assertive statement. Often it is associated with the blurring of the issue and hiding the true speculative character of hypothesis in order to confuse opponents untrained in logical argumentation. According to sound [[science]], the theorist making a historically important claim must assume the responsibility of [[scientific proof|proof]], not the critic.<ref name="Hedtke">{{cite book

'''Shifting the burden of proof''' is an effort to free [[hypothesis]] or persuasive [[argument]] in debate from [[burden of proof]] by shifting it onto opponent. The critic is deliberately placed in the position of trying to prove negative with respect to original assertive statement. Often it is associated with the blurring of the issue and hiding the true speculative character of hypothesis in order to confuse opponents and/or audience untrained in logical argumentation. According to sound [[science]], the theorist making a historically important claim must assume the responsibility of [[scientific proof|proof]], not the critic.<ref name="Hedtke">{{cite book

|author=Randal Hedtke

|author=Randal Hedtke

|title=Secrets of the Sixth Edition

|title=Secrets of the Sixth Edition

|url=http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?pageseq=219&itemID=CUL-DAR121.-&viewtype=side

|url=http://darwin-online.org.uk/content/frameset?pageseq=219&itemID=CUL-DAR121.-&viewtype=side

|accessdate=12 March 2015

|accessdate=12 March 2015

}}</ref> Another evolutionist, [[Alfred Russel Wallace|A.R. Wallace]], after reading Darwin’s statement asserting that useful variations may ''“occur in the course of thousands of generations”'', warned him that such expression may give his opponents the advantage to consider the favorable variations a rare accidents or even never occurring at all. Thus, Wallace advises Darwin to overcome the scientific weakness of his argument by putting the burden of proof to his opponents.<ref>{{cite book

}}</ref> Another evolutionist, [[Alfred Russel Wallace|A.R. Wallace]], after reading Darwin’s statement asserting that useful variations may ''“occur in the course of thousands of generations”'', warned him that such expression may give his opponents the advantage to consider the favorable variations a rare accidents or even never occurring at all.{{#tag:ref|cf. Professor Spetner states that the beneficial mutations required by the theory of evolution have never been observed.<ref name="Spetner">{{Cite book

}}</ref>|group=note}} Thus, Wallace advises Darwin to overcome the scientific weakness of his argument by putting the burden of proof to his opponents.<ref>{{cite book

|author= James Marchant

|author= James Marchant

|title= Alfred Russel Wallace: Letters and Reminiscences (Complete)

|title= Alfred Russel Wallace: Letters and Reminiscences (Complete)

|isbn= 978-1465528643

|isbn= 978-1465528643

|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=0IF1K9IYQYMC&printsec=frontcover&dq=inauthor:#v=onepage&q=%22I%20would%20put%20the%22&f=false |quote=Such expression gives your opponent the advantage of assuming that favorable variations are rare accidents, or even for long periods may never occur at all and thus [the] argument would appear to many to have great force. I would put the burden of proof on my opponent to show that any one organ, structure, or faculty, does not vary, even during one generation… }}</ref>

|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=0IF1K9IYQYMC&printsec=frontcover&dq=inauthor:#v=onepage&q=%22I%20would%20put%20the%22&f=false |quote=Such expression gives your opponent the advantage of assuming that favorable variations are rare accidents, or even for long periods may never occur at all and thus [the] argument would appear to many to have great force. I would put the burden of proof on my opponent to show that any one organ, structure, or faculty, does not vary, even during one generation… }}</ref>

==References==

==References==