Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Adding example
Line 1: Line 1: −
'''Damning the Alternatives''' is a logical fallacy that occurs when someone ranks favorably a certain position by selectively choosing just its pros while treats all other alternatives with bias, emphasizing solely their cons. From logical standpoint, one cannot prove that the position A is a better one or superior to others just by showing that there are difficulties with other positions.  
+
'''Damning the Alternatives''' is a logical fallacy that occurs when someone ranks favorably a certain position by selectively choosing just its pros while treats all other alternatives with bias, emphasizing solely their cons. From logical standpoint, one cannot prove that the position A is a better one or superior to others just by showing that there are difficulties with other positions. In extreme case, the alternative views are intentionally ignored completely or even supressed and their supporters persecuted. 
    
According to [[Karl Popper]], a noted authority on scientific methodology, whenever a [[hypothesis]] appears to a [[scientist]] as the only possible one, it should be taken as a sign that he or she have neither understood the hypothesis nor the problem which it was intended to solve. He also urges investigators to construct ''alternative'' theories - althernatives even to those theories which appear to one inescapable. Only in that way the theories held could be understood.<ref name="Hedtke">{{cite book
 
According to [[Karl Popper]], a noted authority on scientific methodology, whenever a [[hypothesis]] appears to a [[scientist]] as the only possible one, it should be taken as a sign that he or she have neither understood the hypothesis nor the problem which it was intended to solve. He also urges investigators to construct ''alternative'' theories - althernatives even to those theories which appear to one inescapable. Only in that way the theories held could be understood.<ref name="Hedtke">{{cite book
Line 10: Line 10:  
|isbn=978-0-89051-597-6
 
|isbn=978-0-89051-597-6
 
|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=gvyHquVubDoC}}</ref>
 
|url=http://books.google.com/books?id=gvyHquVubDoC}}</ref>
 +
 +
==Examples==
 +
===Antirabies vaccination===
 +
For exploring how [[Pasteur]]'s adversaries adopted ''Damning the Alternatives'' fallacy in effort to discredit his method of antirabies vaccination, ''See:'' [[Disturbed_character#Science_vs._Evolutionism|Disturbed character: Science vs. Evolutionism]].
    
==References==
 
==References==
Block, SkipCaptcha, Automoderated users, edit
2,947

edits

Navigation menu