Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
Line 14: Line 14:     
: '''Yes''' It makes sense, here in America we have the free market system, any economics student can tell you it would be a perfectly logical extension of that market to open war to the lowest bidder. Instead of putting our precious youth in danger, we go to war and have an auction for which companies/mercenary groups want to fight it. The demand for war will be balanced by the supply of mercenaries to fight the war. Soon we won't even have to worry about war; we'll just set up a group akin to the FCC to make sure that various mercenary groups don't break the rules (killing thousands of innocent civilians, using nerve gas to save money, etc.) Plus, since mercenaries aren't armies, they don't have to deal with the Geneva convention or prisoners of war. Halliburton can set up an Invasion Division to take over countries with oil supplies instead of waiting for opportunities, thus growing the US economy. We're better than those countries anyways. [[User:Fuzzy901|Fuzzy901]] 19:00, 6 April 2007 (PST)
 
: '''Yes''' It makes sense, here in America we have the free market system, any economics student can tell you it would be a perfectly logical extension of that market to open war to the lowest bidder. Instead of putting our precious youth in danger, we go to war and have an auction for which companies/mercenary groups want to fight it. The demand for war will be balanced by the supply of mercenaries to fight the war. Soon we won't even have to worry about war; we'll just set up a group akin to the FCC to make sure that various mercenary groups don't break the rules (killing thousands of innocent civilians, using nerve gas to save money, etc.) Plus, since mercenaries aren't armies, they don't have to deal with the Geneva convention or prisoners of war. Halliburton can set up an Invasion Division to take over countries with oil supplies instead of waiting for opportunities, thus growing the US economy. We're better than those countries anyways. [[User:Fuzzy901|Fuzzy901]] 19:00, 6 April 2007 (PST)
 +
 +
==No==
 +
 +
Killing people should not be considered to be a business like any other, like Fuzzy901 said, they fall into a gray area regarding the Geneva conventions, and what about the "enemy combatants" the Bush administration believes do not fall under the Geneva conventions, doesn't that mean that a captured mercenary doesn't either?
 +
Couldn't a country like, let's say Iran detain them indefinitely, like the US do with Taliban and Al Quieda?
 +
 +
Also mercenaries could commit war crimes and get away with it, since they only have a limited command structure, one that is ultimately concerned only about making a profit, some countries already use mercenaries simply so they can commit war crimes without any evidence leading back to the government,  for example the militias in Darfur that are secretely being funded and supplied by the Sudanese government.
 +
 +
Oh, and then there's the price tag, the salaries of mercenaries are up to 4 times higher than that of government soldiers, and guess who's paying them?
 +
That's right, the taxpayer!
 +
 +
Using mercenaries might be an option for shady African regimes, but it shouldn't be for any respectable democratic nation!
 +
 +
[[User:Middle Man|Middle Man]]
447

edits

Navigation menu