128
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 2:
Line 2: − +
Talk:List of atheist shooters and serial killers (view source)
Revision as of 20:20, April 27, 2018
, 20:20, April 27, 2018→Why are there people on this list who aren't atheists?
== Why are there people on this list who aren't atheists? ==
== Why are there people on this list who aren't atheists? ==
I removed [[Kimveer Gill]] and [[James Eagan Holmes]] because there's no evidence that they have ever been [[atheist]]s - yet they've been reinstated without justification. The ref for KG does not mention atheism. The link for JEH explicitly states that he was an [[agnostic]]. By definition, agnostics aren't atheists. A list of atheists should obviously not include anyone who has never been an atheist. [[User:Qaz|Qaz]] ([[User talk:Qaz|talk]]) 16:19, 27 April 2018 (EDT)
I removed [[Kimveer Gill]] and [[James Eagan Holmes]] because there's no evidence that they have ever been [[atheist]]s. They've been reinstated without justification, or even edit summaries. The ref for KG does not mention atheism. The link for JEH explicitly states that he was an [[agnostic]]. By definition, agnostics aren't atheists. A list of atheists should obviously not include anyone who has never been an atheist. [[User:Qaz|Qaz]] ([[User talk:Qaz|talk]]) 16:19, 27 April 2018 (EDT)