Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Christianity much better than you're making out.
Line 44: Line 44:  
:::Please explain how lumping all religions together is so wrong? Islam, Christianity and Judaism are all monotheistic, all believe in the same god and are all similar in a theoretical extent. I am not assuming that because one is wrong they all are, I am saying that they are because I think there is enough evidence that they all have a detrimental effect on society. Good things? I have seen very few. Firstly, look at some of the things a christian world view has brought about. In Australia there was the 'stolen generation'. This was when aboriginal children (aboriginals are the native people of Australia, much the same as American Indians) were taken from their parents by missionaries because they were 'not being brought up the right way'. Thus these children were denied there parents and as a result, aboriginal society has been fractured and almost destroyed. Then of course, there is the crusades, death and disease being the only outcomes of these misguided 'religious wars'. Don't forget the Inquisition or the witch hunts of the medieval times. Christianity has done far far more evil to the world than it has done good, just as with all the other religions.  
 
:::Please explain how lumping all religions together is so wrong? Islam, Christianity and Judaism are all monotheistic, all believe in the same god and are all similar in a theoretical extent. I am not assuming that because one is wrong they all are, I am saying that they are because I think there is enough evidence that they all have a detrimental effect on society. Good things? I have seen very few. Firstly, look at some of the things a christian world view has brought about. In Australia there was the 'stolen generation'. This was when aboriginal children (aboriginals are the native people of Australia, much the same as American Indians) were taken from their parents by missionaries because they were 'not being brought up the right way'. Thus these children were denied there parents and as a result, aboriginal society has been fractured and almost destroyed. Then of course, there is the crusades, death and disease being the only outcomes of these misguided 'religious wars'. Don't forget the Inquisition or the witch hunts of the medieval times. Christianity has done far far more evil to the world than it has done good, just as with all the other religions.  
 
:::Heart of Gold, I assume you meant athiestic when you said religious in your post about Chairman Mao and Stalin? Please correct me if you haven't. [[User:Bolly Ottihw|Bolly Ottihw]] 19:40, 10 May 2007
 
:::Heart of Gold, I assume you meant athiestic when you said religious in your post about Chairman Mao and Stalin? Please correct me if you haven't. [[User:Bolly Ottihw|Bolly Ottihw]] 19:40, 10 May 2007
 +
 +
:::: Islam and Judaism deny the Divinity of Jesus, for one thing.  They can't all be correct on that.
 +
:::: As for the effects of Christianity on society, please read this review of [http://www.creationontheweb.com/content/view/1581/ For The Glory of God: How Monotheism Led to Reformations, Science, Witch-hunts and the End of Slavery].
 +
:::: The 'stolen generation' is an urban myth, with most examples of "stolen" children not being stolen at all.  And to the extent that any were taken against their parents' will, it was generally by governments, not missionaries.
 +
:::: The Crusades were, in part, a military action to stop and reverse the invasions by Muslims of various countries.
 +
:::: [[User:Philip J. Rayment|Philip J. Rayment]] 06:25, 10 May 2007 (EDT)
nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW
13,254

edits

Navigation menu