Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 45: Line 45:  
: Uh... then how do you explain conversions (Muslim to Christian, for example)? - [[User:JCasto]]
 
: Uh... then how do you explain conversions (Muslim to Christian, for example)? - [[User:JCasto]]
 
::Or the other way round for that matter,  I think that more Christians convert to Muslims than vice versa.  No data, just the impression from certain high profile conversions like Muhammed Ali or Yusuf Islam.  The problem is that religion is not based on logic but on emotion.  If someone is brought up in a certain faith and they are not getting what they need from it then they will look for something else.  Sometimes it is a wholesale conversion, othertimes it is supplementing with other beliefs; such as Nancy Reagan with astrology. Being a psychological thing it is very difficult to explain any of it.  How does one explain the Mormon church or Islam?  They only exist through the word an individual (no offence intended).  Sufficiently charismatic people can persuade others to do things, or believe things that they might not otherwise do.  Some of it can be explained but charlatans prefer that it is not so they can dupe the gullible.  Anyone want to buy a bridge in London? [[User:Ian St John|Ian St John]] 19:26, 10 May 2007 (EDT)
 
::Or the other way round for that matter,  I think that more Christians convert to Muslims than vice versa.  No data, just the impression from certain high profile conversions like Muhammed Ali or Yusuf Islam.  The problem is that religion is not based on logic but on emotion.  If someone is brought up in a certain faith and they are not getting what they need from it then they will look for something else.  Sometimes it is a wholesale conversion, othertimes it is supplementing with other beliefs; such as Nancy Reagan with astrology. Being a psychological thing it is very difficult to explain any of it.  How does one explain the Mormon church or Islam?  They only exist through the word an individual (no offence intended).  Sufficiently charismatic people can persuade others to do things, or believe things that they might not otherwise do.  Some of it can be explained but charlatans prefer that it is not so they can dupe the gullible.  Anyone want to buy a bridge in London? [[User:Ian St John|Ian St John]] 19:26, 10 May 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
There is a verified quote by Hubbard who said "Writing for a penny a word is ridiculous. If a man really wants to make a million dollars, the best way would be to start his own religion."
 +
 +
As the story goes, Heinlein and Hubbard were sitting in a bar one night with a bunch of other SF authors. The bet theory goes that RAH and LRH made a bet as to who could start a religion.  According to this theory [[Stranger in a Strange Land]] was Heinlein's entry to the bet, and Dianetics was Hubbard's.  One of those authors was [[Harlan Ellison]] - a transcript of his interview in the '70s adds some background to the bet theory [http://www.islets.net/faq.html#Anchor-Was-47857 Harlan Ellison website (warning, contains foul language)].  This may well be [[urban legend]], but I'm inclined to believe it to have more truth than fiction.
 +
 +
That said, the idea behind Scientology is one that closely mirrors Gnostic beliefs - Hubbard drew from history for his material.  An interesting book to read on the subject is ''The Lost Christianities: The Battles for Scripture and the Faiths We Never Knew''[http://www.amazon.com/Lost-Christianities-Battles-Scripture-Faiths/dp/0195141830] which goes into some of the gnostic beliefs of some sects of early Christianity.  The parallels between Scientology and early gnostic Christianity are very strong.
 +
 +
Within Scientology, you have the full range of people who practice - as you do in any religion.  You have those who are trying to find meaning in their life.  You have those trying to make money.  You have those who are trying to convert/save others.
 +
 +
While the origins of Scientology are debateably monetarily inclined, there are people for whom it gives a direction in life.  To that extent, Scientology is an institutionalized system of attitudes, beliefs, and practices and it is an honest religion for some people.  I don't believe it was conceived as such originally. --[[User:Mtur|Mtur]] 19:31, 10 May 2007 (EDT)
1,129

edits

Navigation menu