::::::What dictionaries give ''is'' indeed a definition. It sets boundaries for a meaning of a word. You can talk about whether it is a correct or an incorrect definition, but it's a definition. Dictionaries do, as you say, say they document the meaning of the word ''as it is currently used'' by most educated people. However, one of the reasons I like the AHD is that in cases where usage is uncertain or controversial, the definition or definitions are followed by a paragraph or two summarizing the opinions of their usage panel as to how it ''ought'' to be used. There's no such paragraph here, so they've judged this is not a term where the usage is disputed. | ::::::What dictionaries give ''is'' indeed a definition. It sets boundaries for a meaning of a word. You can talk about whether it is a correct or an incorrect definition, but it's a definition. Dictionaries do, as you say, say they document the meaning of the word ''as it is currently used'' by most educated people. However, one of the reasons I like the AHD is that in cases where usage is uncertain or controversial, the definition or definitions are followed by a paragraph or two summarizing the opinions of their usage panel as to how it ''ought'' to be used. There's no such paragraph here, so they've judged this is not a term where the usage is disputed. |