| Line 543: |
Line 543: |
| | *'''27 June.''' '''Tarmac collusion.''' [[Bill Clinton]] meets Attn. Gen. Loretta Lynch in a face-to-face meeting on board her plane at an airport hanger in Phoenix,<!--environment that eliminated a paper trail and to avoid NSA electronic metadata collection. It is said Lynch authorized the Justice Dept. to proceed with a FISA warrant application after this meeting.<ref>"[https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-38589427 Trump 'compromising' claims: How and why did we get here?]", BBC, Jan. 12, 2017.</ref>--> apparently to make final arrangements for Hillary Clinton's July 3 interview. | | *'''27 June.''' '''Tarmac collusion.''' [[Bill Clinton]] meets Attn. Gen. Loretta Lynch in a face-to-face meeting on board her plane at an airport hanger in Phoenix,<!--environment that eliminated a paper trail and to avoid NSA electronic metadata collection. It is said Lynch authorized the Justice Dept. to proceed with a FISA warrant application after this meeting.<ref>"[https://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-38589427 Trump 'compromising' claims: How and why did we get here?]", BBC, Jan. 12, 2017.</ref>--> apparently to make final arrangements for Hillary Clinton's July 3 interview. |
| | | | |
| − | *The head of Clinton's [[Secret Service]] detail contacted the head of Lynch's FBI security detail before her arrival hours in advance to arrange the meeting. Clinton's private plane waited for Lynch's arrival, yet Clinton lied to Inspector General [[Michael Horowitz]] that he did not know Lynch was coming to Phoenix until her arrival, and it was a last minute, spontaneous decision to board her plane and speak with her.<ref>Horowitz Report, pp. 203-204.</ref> | + | *The head of Clinton's [[Secret Service]] detail contacted the head of Lynch's FBI security detail before her arrival hours in advance to arrange the meeting. Clinton's private plane waited for Lynch's arrival, yet Clinton lied to Inspector General [[Michael Horowitz]] that he did not know Lynch was coming to Phoenix until her arrival, and it was a last minute, spontaneous decision to board her plane and speak with her.<ref>Clinton email IG Report, pp. 203-204.</ref> |
| | | | |
| | *The Inspector General criticised Lynch's participation and failure to recuse an error in judgement, her explanations did not adequately address the situation, and created confusion among the public whether the justice system works. | | *The Inspector General criticised Lynch's participation and failure to recuse an error in judgement, her explanations did not adequately address the situation, and created confusion among the public whether the justice system works. |
| Line 986: |
Line 986: |
| | :{{quotebox|'''Q''': “So what you’re saying is, is that you had no knowledge of these potential unverified memos prior to the middle part of September in your investigation?”<br>'''Page''': “That is correct, sir.”<ref>https://www.theepochtimes.com/transcripts-of-lisa-pages-closed-door-testimonies-provide-new-revelations_2763452.html</ref>}} | | :{{quotebox|'''Q''': “So what you’re saying is, is that you had no knowledge of these potential unverified memos prior to the middle part of September in your investigation?”<br>'''Page''': “That is correct, sir.”<ref>https://www.theepochtimes.com/transcripts-of-lisa-pages-closed-door-testimonies-provide-new-revelations_2763452.html</ref>}} |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| − | Strzok and Lisa Page discuss how to circumvent FBI investigation document preservation laws: {{Quotebox|Page - Have a meeting with turgal about getting iphone in a day or so<br>Strzok - Oh hot damn. . . We get around our security/monitoring issues?<br>Page - No, he’s proposing that we just stop following them. Apparently the requirement to capture texts came from [Office of Management and Budget], but we’re the only org (I’m told) who is following that rule. His point is, if no one else is doing it why should we. . . I’m told – thought I have seen – that there is an IG report that says everyone is failing. But one has changed anything, so why not just join in the failure.<ref>https://thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/371853-new-fbi-messages-reveal-agents-searching-for-way-to-evade-record</ref>}} | + | Strzok and Lisa Page discuss how to circumvent FBI investigation document preservation laws: {{Quotebox|Page - Have a meeting with turgal about getting iphone in a day or so<br>Strzok - Oh hot damn. . . We get around our security/monitoring issues?<br>Page - No, he’s proposing that we just stop following them. Apparently the requirement to capture texts came from [Office of Management and Budget], but we’re the only org (I’m told) who is following that rule. His point is, if no one else is doing it why should we. . . I’m told – thought I have seen – that there is an Clinton email that says everyone is failing. But one has changed anything, so why not just join in the failure.<ref>https://thehill.com/opinion/criminal-justice/371853-new-fbi-messages-reveal-agents-searching-for-way-to-evade-record</ref>}} |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| | *'''31 August.''' Perkins Coie makes a payment of $157,753.61 to FusionGPS. | | *'''31 August.''' Perkins Coie makes a payment of $157,753.61 to FusionGPS. |
| Line 1,099: |
Line 1,099: |
| | *Comey finds out about Weiner laptop.<ref>[https://t.co/fcXkUbth6C Comey transcript, December 8, 2018. Question and response from Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, p. 172-173].</ref> | | *Comey finds out about Weiner laptop.<ref>[https://t.co/fcXkUbth6C Comey transcript, December 8, 2018. Question and response from Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, p. 172-173].</ref> |
| | | | |
| − | *'''26-27 September.''' IG report states: {{quotebox|'''The case agent assigned to the Weiner investigation was certified as a Digital Extraction Technician''' and, as such, had the training and skills to extract digital evidence from electronic devices.<br>The case agent told the OIG that he began processing Weiner’s devices upon receipt on September 26. The case agent stated that he noticed “within hours” that there were “over 300,000 emails on the laptop.”<br>The case agent told us that on either the evening of September 26 or the morning of September 27, he noticed the software program on his workstation '''was having trouble processing the data''' on the laptop.}} | + | *'''26-27 September.''' Clinton email IG Report states: {{quotebox|'''The case agent assigned to the Weiner investigation was certified as a Digital Extraction Technician''' and, as such, had the training and skills to extract digital evidence from electronic devices.<br>The case agent told the OIG that he began processing Weiner’s devices upon receipt on September 26. The case agent stated that he noticed “within hours” that there were “over 300,000 emails on the laptop.”<br>The case agent told us that on either the evening of September 26 or the morning of September 27, he noticed the software program on his workstation '''was having trouble processing the data''' on the laptop.}} |
| | | | |
| | :*The case aagent saw at least one BlackBerry PIN message between Hillary Clinton and Huma Abedin, as well as emails between them. He saw emails associated with “about seven domains,” such as yahoo.com, state.gov, clintonfoundation.org, clintonemail.com, and hillaryclinton.com. The case agent immediately notified his FBI New York Office (NYO) chain of command, and the information was ultimately briefed to NYO Assistant Director in Charge (ADIC)<!--William Sweeney--> | | :*The case aagent saw at least one BlackBerry PIN message between Hillary Clinton and Huma Abedin, as well as emails between them. He saw emails associated with “about seven domains,” such as yahoo.com, state.gov, clintonfoundation.org, clintonemail.com, and hillaryclinton.com. The case agent immediately notified his FBI New York Office (NYO) chain of command, and the information was ultimately briefed to NYO Assistant Director in Charge (ADIC)<!--William Sweeney--> |
| Line 1,146: |
Line 1,146: |
| | *CEPA Forum was hosted at the Meridian International Center in Washington, DC, where it was attended by Director General Mikk Marran, Michael Weiss and Lawfare’s [[Benjamin Wittes]], a friend of James Comey and James Baker (DOJ).<ref>https://web.archive.org/web/20170713171014/https://www.cepaforum.org/2016/Program</ref> | | *CEPA Forum was hosted at the Meridian International Center in Washington, DC, where it was attended by Director General Mikk Marran, Michael Weiss and Lawfare’s [[Benjamin Wittes]], a friend of James Comey and James Baker (DOJ).<ref>https://web.archive.org/web/20170713171014/https://www.cepaforum.org/2016/Program</ref> |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| − | *'''30 September.''' Inspector General report on [[Awan investigation|Imran Awan]] and his family members; they were logging into the servers of members who had previously fired him, funneling data off the network, and that evidence “suggests steps are being taken to conceal their activity.” Shortly after the IG report came out in September 2016, the Caucus server — identified as prime evidence in the cybersecurity case — physically disappeared. No official body has ever publicly provided any information about the case.<ref>https://dailycaller.com/2018/04/20/ig-pakistani-mystery-man-imran-awan/</ref> | + | *'''30 September.''' Inspector General report on [[Awan investigation|Imran Awan]] and his family members; they were logging into the servers of members who had previously fired him, funneling data off the network, and that evidence “suggests steps are being taken to conceal their activity.” Shortly after the Clinton email IG Report came out in September 2016, the Caucus server — identified as prime evidence in the cybersecurity case — physically disappeared. No official body has ever publicly provided any information about the case.<ref>https://dailycaller.com/2018/04/20/ig-pakistani-mystery-man-imran-awan/</ref> |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| | *Perkins Coie makes a payment of $144,643.46 to FusionGPS. | | *Perkins Coie makes a payment of $144,643.46 to FusionGPS. |
| Line 1,232: |
Line 1,232: |
| | *'''3-4 October.''' Additional discussions between NYO and Washington HQ about Weiner laptop, however the Inspector General found {{quotebox|"no evidence that anyone associated with the Midyear [Clinton email] investigation, including the entire leadership team at FBI Headquarters, took any action on the Weiner laptop issue until the week of October 24, and then did so only after the Weiner case agent expressed concerns to SDNY, prompting SDNY to contact the Office of the Deputy Attorney General (ODAG) on October 21 to raise concerns about the lack of action."}} They were anticipating a Hillary win. | | *'''3-4 October.''' Additional discussions between NYO and Washington HQ about Weiner laptop, however the Inspector General found {{quotebox|"no evidence that anyone associated with the Midyear [Clinton email] investigation, including the entire leadership team at FBI Headquarters, took any action on the Weiner laptop issue until the week of October 24, and then did so only after the Weiner case agent expressed concerns to SDNY, prompting SDNY to contact the Office of the Deputy Attorney General (ODAG) on October 21 to raise concerns about the lack of action."}} They were anticipating a Hillary win. |
| | | | |
| − | *'''4 October 8:15 am – 9:00 am.''' '''Comey briefed on Weiner and Clinton Foundation child sex crimes.''' Comey briefing with Executive Assistant Director Randy Coleman. Coleman notes state topic: {{quotebox|(1) Anthony Wiener [sic]<br><br>(2) [Unrelated]<br><br>(3) Wiener [sic] – texting 15 yo – Sexually Explicit<br><br>9/26 – Federal SW [search warrant] IPhone/IPAD/Laptop<br><br>Initial analysis of laptop – thousands emails<br><br>Hillary Clinton & Foundation<br><br>Crime Against Children<ref>IG Report, p. 293.</ref>}} | + | *'''4 October 8:15 am – 9:00 am.''' '''Comey briefed on Weiner and Clinton Foundation child sex crimes.''' Comey briefing with Executive Assistant Director Randy Coleman. Coleman notes state topic: {{quotebox|(1) Anthony Wiener [sic]<br><br>(2) [Unrelated]<br><br>(3) Wiener [sic] – texting 15 yo – Sexually Explicit<br><br>9/26 – Federal SW [search warrant] IPhone/IPAD/Laptop<br><br>Initial analysis of laptop – thousands emails<br><br>Hillary Clinton & Foundation<br><br>Crime Against Children<ref>Clinton email IG Report, p. 293.</ref>}} |
| | | | |
| | *Standard follow-up hearing on the DOJ-NSD 2016 Section 702 Certification was held before the FISA court.<ref>United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillence Court, Memorandum Opinion and Order, April 26, 2017, p. 19.</ref> John Carlin was present at the hearing. Again, Carlin made no disclosure of FISA abuse. This would be noted by the Court later. | | *Standard follow-up hearing on the DOJ-NSD 2016 Section 702 Certification was held before the FISA court.<ref>United States Foreign Intelligence Surveillence Court, Memorandum Opinion and Order, April 26, 2017, p. 19.</ref> John Carlin was present at the hearing. Again, Carlin made no disclosure of FISA abuse. This would be noted by the Court later. |
| Line 1,308: |
Line 1,308: |
| | *The Origins of the Prague Narrative: ''Steele’s dossier'' memo reads: {{quotebox|''“Kremlin insider reports Trump lawyer COHEN’s secret meeting/s with Kremlin officials in August 2016 was/were held in Prague."''<ref>https://themarketswork.com/2018/12/29/why-did-foreign-intel-agencies-leak-info-on-alleged-cohen-prague-visit-now/</ref>}} No more Steele memos until Dec. 13. | | *The Origins of the Prague Narrative: ''Steele’s dossier'' memo reads: {{quotebox|''“Kremlin insider reports Trump lawyer COHEN’s secret meeting/s with Kremlin officials in August 2016 was/were held in Prague."''<ref>https://themarketswork.com/2018/12/29/why-did-foreign-intel-agencies-leak-info-on-alleged-cohen-prague-visit-now/</ref>}} No more Steele memos until Dec. 13. |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| − | *IG report states: {{Quotebox|AUSAs met with their supervisors at SDNY and informed them of their conversation with the Weiner case agent. The AUSAs stated that they told their supervisors the substantive information reported by the case agent, the case agent’s concerns that no one at the FBI had expressed interest in this information, and their concern that the case agent was stressed out and might act out in some way. (pg 304)}} | + | *Clinton email IG Report states: {{Quotebox|AUSAs met with their supervisors at SDNY and informed them of their conversation with the Weiner case agent. The AUSAs stated that they told their supervisors the substantive information reported by the case agent, the case agent’s concerns that no one at the FBI had expressed interest in this information, and their concern that the case agent was stressed out and might act out in some way. (pg 304)}} |
| − | :Midyeaar IG report Page 274, footnote #165: {{Quotebox|No electronic record exists of the case agent’s initial review of the Weiner laptop. The case agent told us that at some point in mid-October 2016 the NYO ASAC '''instructed the case agent to wipe his work station'''. The case agent explained that the ASAC was concerned about the presence of potentially classified information on the case agent’s work station, which was not authorized to process classified information.<br>The case agent told us that he followed the ASAC’s instructions, but that this request concerned him because the audit trail of his initial processing of the laptop would no longer be available. The case agent clarified that none of the evidence on the Weiner laptop was impacted by this, explaining that the FBI retained the Weiner laptop and only the image that had been copied onto his work station was deleted. The ASAC recalled that the case agent “worked through the security department to address the concern” of classified information on an unclassified system. He told us that he did not recall how the issue was resolved.}} | + | :Midyeaar Clinton email IG Report Page 274, footnote #165: {{Quotebox|No electronic record exists of the case agent’s initial review of the Weiner laptop. The case agent told us that at some point in mid-October 2016 the NYO ASAC '''instructed the case agent to wipe his work station'''. The case agent explained that the ASAC was concerned about the presence of potentially classified information on the case agent’s work station, which was not authorized to process classified information.<br>The case agent told us that he followed the ASAC’s instructions, but that this request concerned him because the audit trail of his initial processing of the laptop would no longer be available. The case agent clarified that none of the evidence on the Weiner laptop was impacted by this, explaining that the FBI retained the Weiner laptop and only the image that had been copied onto his work station was deleted. The ASAC recalled that the case agent “worked through the security department to address the concern” of classified information on an unclassified system. He told us that he did not recall how the issue was resolved.}} |
| | :*Devin Nunes says FBI whistleblowers in NYO informed him the FBI was sitting on Weiner laptop.<ref>pic.twitter.com/BU6ysY7Xwn</ref> | | :*Devin Nunes says FBI whistleblowers in NYO informed him the FBI was sitting on Weiner laptop.<ref>pic.twitter.com/BU6ysY7Xwn</ref> |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| Line 1,371: |
Line 1,371: |
| | With McCabe' sitting on the Clinton emails from Weiner's computer for three weeks, along with pressure from the SDNY, Loretta Lynch and media leaks, the internal debate at the DOJ and FBI about McCabe recusing himself from the Clinton investigations continues. | | With McCabe' sitting on the Clinton emails from Weiner's computer for three weeks, along with pressure from the SDNY, Loretta Lynch and media leaks, the internal debate at the DOJ and FBI about McCabe recusing himself from the Clinton investigations continues. |
| | | | |
| − | *OIG report states, {{quotebox|"McCabe and the New York Assistant Director in Charge (NY-ADIC) participated in what McCabe described as “a hastily convened conference call with the Attorney General [Loretta Lynch] who delivered the same message to us” about leaks, with specific focus being on leaks regarding the high-profile investigation by FBI’s New York Field Office into the death of Eric Garner. McCabe told us that he “never heard her use more forceful language.” NY-ADIC confirmed that the participants got “ripped by the AG on leaks.”}} | + | *Clinton email IG Report states, {{quotebox|"McCabe and the New York Assistant Director in Charge (NY-ADIC) participated in what McCabe described as “a hastily convened conference call with the Attorney General [Loretta Lynch] who delivered the same message to us” about leaks, with specific focus being on leaks regarding the high-profile investigation by FBI’s New York Field Office into the death of Eric Garner. McCabe told us that he “never heard her use more forceful language.” NY-ADIC confirmed that the participants got “ripped by the AG on leaks.”}} |
| | | | |
| | *McCabe told OIG that he proposed that the Clinton email team meet with Comey the following day after the conference call between the the NYO and SDNY. | | *McCabe told OIG that he proposed that the Clinton email team meet with Comey the following day after the conference call between the the NYO and SDNY. |
| Line 1,444: |
Line 1,444: |
| | *Steele could have been terminated earlier for his previous undisclosed contacts with Michael Isikoff of ''Yahoo News'' and other media outlets in September 2016 - before the Carter Page application was submitted to the FISA court in October 2016 - but Steele improperly concealed and lied to the FBI about earlier contacts. DOJ official Bruce Ohr continued to pass along allegations from Steele to the FBI after the FBI suspended its formal relationship with Steele, and demonstrates that Bruce Ohr funneled allegations from FusionGPS and Steele to the FBI. | | *Steele could have been terminated earlier for his previous undisclosed contacts with Michael Isikoff of ''Yahoo News'' and other media outlets in September 2016 - before the Carter Page application was submitted to the FISA court in October 2016 - but Steele improperly concealed and lied to the FBI about earlier contacts. DOJ official Bruce Ohr continued to pass along allegations from Steele to the FBI after the FBI suspended its formal relationship with Steele, and demonstrates that Bruce Ohr funneled allegations from FusionGPS and Steele to the FBI. |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| − | *Devlin Barrett of the ''Wall Street Journal'' publishes an article entitled, ''FBI in Internal Feud Over Hillary Clinton Probe,'' based on illegal leaks ultimately leading to the firing of [[Andrew McCabe]] for misconduct and lying to investigators.<ref>https://www.scribd.com/document/376296306/DOJ-OIG-Report-on-Andrew-McCabe-April-13th-Release?campaign=SkimbitLtd&ad_group=725X700959X71d69d99c58d16967f9220546379e02c&keyword=660149026&source=hp_affiliate&medium=affiliate</ref> The article was the first public acknowledgement that the Clinton Foundation was under FBI investigation.<ref>http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/10/by-the-way-the-fbi-was-investigating-the-clinton-foundation.html</ref> According to the OIG report on McCabe, {{quotebox|The article highlighted the campaign donations to McCabe’s wife by PACs associated with Gov. [[Terry McAuliffe]], who was described as “a longtime ally of the Clintons and . . . a Clinton Foundation Board member.” The article identified McCabe as the FBI official who “sought to refocus the Clinton Foundation probe,” and reported that '''agents “further down the FBI chain of command” had been told to “stand down” on the Clinton Foundation''' investigation with the understanding that “the order had come from the deputy director — Mr. McCabe.”}} | + | *Devlin Barrett of the ''Wall Street Journal'' publishes an article entitled, ''FBI in Internal Feud Over Hillary Clinton Probe,'' based on illegal leaks ultimately leading to the firing of [[Andrew McCabe]] for misconduct and lying to investigators.<ref>https://www.scribd.com/document/376296306/DOJ-OIG-Report-on-Andrew-McCabe-April-13th-Release?campaign=SkimbitLtd&ad_group=725X700959X71d69d99c58d16967f9220546379e02c&keyword=660149026&source=hp_affiliate&medium=affiliate</ref> The article was the first public acknowledgement that the Clinton Foundation was under FBI investigation.<ref>http://nymag.com/daily/intelligencer/2016/10/by-the-way-the-fbi-was-investigating-the-clinton-foundation.html</ref> According to the IG Report on McCabe, {{quotebox|The article highlighted the campaign donations to McCabe’s wife by PACs associated with Gov. [[Terry McAuliffe]], who was described as “a longtime ally of the Clintons and . . . a Clinton Foundation Board member.” The article identified McCabe as the FBI official who “sought to refocus the Clinton Foundation probe,” and reported that '''agents “further down the FBI chain of command” had been told to “stand down” on the Clinton Foundation''' investigation with the understanding that “the order had come from the deputy director — Mr. McCabe.”}} |
| | ---- | | ---- |
| | *Democrat Minority leader [[Harry Reid]] issues open letter to James Comey: Reid says from his communications with “other top officials in the national security community [John Brennan for example, August 15, 2016] it has become clear that you possess explosive information about close ties and coordination between Donald Trump, his top advisers and the Russian government."<ref>https://m.facebook.com/SenatorReid/posts/1524069540941657</ref> | | *Democrat Minority leader [[Harry Reid]] issues open letter to James Comey: Reid says from his communications with “other top officials in the national security community [John Brennan for example, August 15, 2016] it has become clear that you possess explosive information about close ties and coordination between Donald Trump, his top advisers and the Russian government."<ref>https://m.facebook.com/SenatorReid/posts/1524069540941657</ref> |