Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
540 bytes removed ,  18:53, May 14, 2007
→‎Examples: poor example
Line 25: Line 25:     
might be considered an ad hominem attack on Wagner's music.  It is true, and in some contexts might be a relevant comment.  But if someone says it in order to suggest that Wagner was a bad composer, then it's an ad hominem attack, because whether some bad people liked his music is not a relevant comment on the quality of his music.
 
might be considered an ad hominem attack on Wagner's music.  It is true, and in some contexts might be a relevant comment.  But if someone says it in order to suggest that Wagner was a bad composer, then it's an ad hominem attack, because whether some bad people liked his music is not a relevant comment on the quality of his music.
−
  −
As another example, the statement
  −
  −
:'The [[atheist]] [[Karl Marx]] believed in taking wealth from the rich and redistributing it to the poor'
  −
  −
might be considered an ad hominem attack on the policy of income redistribution. Karl Marx may or may not have been right to advocate income redistribution; but whether he was an atheist is irrelevant to that question. So if the speaker mentions that he is atheist (to someone who considers atheism bad) when the topic under discussion is income distribution, then that's an ad hominem attack.
      
== Ad Hominem Not Always Fallacious ==
 
== Ad Hominem Not Always Fallacious ==
Block, Siteadmin, SkipCaptcha, Upload, Automoderated users, delete, edit, move, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, protect, rollback, Administrators, template
296,945

edits

Navigation menu