Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
11 bytes added ,  21:55, February 21, 2020
Line 61: Line 61:  
In July 1949, her ambivalent attitude toward American Catholics caused a high visibility fight with [[Francis Cardinal Spellman]], the Catholic Archbishop of New York.<ref>For details on the Spellman dispute see Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone'' pp 156-65 and Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' pp 498-502, noting it was "a battle still remembered for its vehemence and hostility." p. 498.</ref> In her columns, Eleanor had attacked proposals for federal funding of certain (nonreligious) activities, such as bus transportation for students, at Catholic schools. Spellman pointed out that the Supreme Court had recently upheld such provisions, and accused her of anti-Catholicism. Most Democrats rallied behind Roosevelt, so Spellman came to Eleanor's Hyde Park home to bury the hatchet. However, Eleanor retained her belief that Catholic schools should not receive federal aid. She seems to have paid attention to the anti-Catholic polemics of people like [[Paul Blanshard]].<ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone''  p. 157</ref> Privately, she said that if Catholics got school aid, "Once that is done they control the schools, or at least a great part of them."<ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone''  p. 164</ref>   
 
In July 1949, her ambivalent attitude toward American Catholics caused a high visibility fight with [[Francis Cardinal Spellman]], the Catholic Archbishop of New York.<ref>For details on the Spellman dispute see Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone'' pp 156-65 and Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' pp 498-502, noting it was "a battle still remembered for its vehemence and hostility." p. 498.</ref> In her columns, Eleanor had attacked proposals for federal funding of certain (nonreligious) activities, such as bus transportation for students, at Catholic schools. Spellman pointed out that the Supreme Court had recently upheld such provisions, and accused her of anti-Catholicism. Most Democrats rallied behind Roosevelt, so Spellman came to Eleanor's Hyde Park home to bury the hatchet. However, Eleanor retained her belief that Catholic schools should not receive federal aid. She seems to have paid attention to the anti-Catholic polemics of people like [[Paul Blanshard]].<ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone''  p. 157</ref> Privately, she said that if Catholics got school aid, "Once that is done they control the schools, or at least a great part of them."<ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone''  p. 164</ref>   
   −
Mrs. Roosevelt was never as popular among Catholics as her husband. While he kept the country neutral in the [[Spanish Civil War]], she openly favored the republican Loyalists (who were anticlerical) against General [[Francisco Franco]]'s Nationalists (whom many American Catholics favored); after 1945, she opposed normalizing relations with Spain.<ref>Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' p 492</ref> She told Spellman bluntly that "I cannot however say that in European countries the control by the Roman Catholic Church of great areas of land has always led to happiness for the people of those countries." <ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone'' pp 159.</ref> Catholics resented her quiet support of [[Margaret Sanger]] and the birth control movement,<ref>Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' pp 60-62</ref> and her prewar sponsorship of the [[American Youth Congress]], in which the Communists had been heavily represented, but Catholic youth groups were not represented.<ref>Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' p 16-19</ref>  In 1960 she actively opposed [[John F. Kennedy]]'s quest for the presidential nomination in part because, biographer Lash has concluded, "Somewhere deep in her subconscious was an anti-Catholicism which was a part of her Protestant heritage." <ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone''
+
Mrs. Roosevelt was never as popular among Catholics as her husband. While he kept the country neutral in the [[Spanish Civil War]], she openly favored the republican Loyalists (who were anticlerical) against General [[Francisco Franco]]'s Nationalists (whom many American Catholics favored); after 1945, she opposed normalizing relations with Spain.<ref>Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' p 492</ref> She told Spellman bluntly that "I cannot however say that in European countries the control by the Roman Catholic Church of great areas of land has always led to happiness for the people of those countries." <ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone'' pp 159.</ref> Catholics resented her quiet support of [[Margaret Sanger]] and the birth control movement,<ref>Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' pp 60-62</ref> and her prewar sponsorship of the [[American Youth Congress]], in which the Communists had been heavily represented, but Catholic youth groups were not represented.<ref>Beasley, ''Eleanor Roosevelt Encyclopedia'' p 16-19</ref>  In 1960 she actively opposed [[John F. Kennedy]]'s quest for the presidential nomination in part because, biographer [[Joseph Lash]] has concluded, "Somewhere deep in her subconscious was an anti-Catholicism which was a part of her Protestant heritage." <ref>Lash, ''Eleanor: The Years Alone''
 
p 282</ref>  Her son [[Elliott Roosevelt]] suggested that her "reservations about Catholicism" were rooted in her husband's sexual affairs with Lucy Mercer and Missy LeHand, who were both Catholics.<ref>Elliot Roosevelt and James Brough (1973) ''An Untold Story'', New York: Dell, p.282.</ref>
 
p 282</ref>  Her son [[Elliott Roosevelt]] suggested that her "reservations about Catholicism" were rooted in her husband's sexual affairs with Lucy Mercer and Missy LeHand, who were both Catholics.<ref>Elliot Roosevelt and James Brough (1973) ''An Untold Story'', New York: Dell, p.282.</ref>
  
Block, Siteadmin, SkipCaptcha, Upload, Automoderated users, delete, edit, move, nsTeam2RO, nsTeam2RW, nsTeam2_talkRO, nsTeam2_talkRW, protect, rollback, Administrators, template
297,196

edits

Navigation menu