Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 112: Line 112:  
         In his book "The Selfish Gene" (Dawkins, 1976) Dawkins argues that the gene is the unit of natural selection.  
 
         In his book "The Selfish Gene" (Dawkins, 1976) Dawkins argues that the gene is the unit of natural selection.  
 
This book was criticised by Rose, Lewontin and Kamin in their book "Not In Our Genes" for promoting genetic determinism.  
 
This book was criticised by Rose, Lewontin and Kamin in their book "Not In Our Genes" for promoting genetic determinism.  
−
Edward Wilson, at one time a proponent of sociobiology, has now expressed skepticism about the selfish gene theory. In "The Selfish Gene", Dawkins talks about new replicators  - memes  - which are units of cultural evolution. This idea has been criticised by cultural anthropologists for taking too reductionistic a view of cultural evolution, they have argued that a more holistic view of how cultures change is needed. It has been pointed that memes are not copied (as the name, from the French for "same" implies) but recreated. It has also been noted that cultural transmission is tied up with development. Dawkins' writings on memes, which he calls "the new replicators" (after genes) shows a vast ignorance of developmental psychology.  
+
Edward Wilson, at one time a proponent of sociobiology, has now expressed skepticism about the selfish gene theory. In "The Selfish Gene", Dawkins talks about new replicators  - memes  - which are units of cultural evolution. This idea has been criticised by cultural anthropologists for taking too reductionistic a view of cultural evolution, they have argued that a more holistic view of how cultures change is needed. It has been pointed that memes are not copied (as the name, from the French for "same" implies) but recreated. It has also been noted that cultural transmission is tied up with development. Dawkins' writings on memes, which he calls "the new replicators" (after genes) shows a vast ignorance of developmental psychology. The view that the gene should be seen as the unit of natural selection has been criticised on the website resilience.org/stories/2017-08-08/the_dangerous_delusions_of_Richard_Dawkins. This website says that modern science emphasises more holistic entities than the gene, such as complex systems or the environment. It also says that the idea that a gene can be selfish is absurd, and was merely meant by Dawkins as a metaphor.  
     
SkipCaptcha
339

edits

Navigation menu