Changes

The panel majority cited about 130 precedents, while the dissent cited about 20.

The panel majority cited about 130 precedents, while the dissent cited about 20.

The panel majority shredded a contrary decision by the [[Eleventh Circuit]] in ''[[NetChoice v. AG, Fla.]]'' (May 23, 2022), thoroughly debunking its reasoning with 11 pages of analysis at Slip Op. pp. 79-89.

The panel majority shredded a contrary decision by the [[Eleventh Circuit]] in ''[[NetChoice v. AG, Fla.]]'' (May 23, 2022), as the [[Fifth Circuit]] thoroughly debunked the reasoning by the [[Eleventh Circuit]] with 11 pages of analysis at Slip Op. pp. 79-89.

== Panel Majority's Reasoning ==

== Panel Majority's Reasoning ==

{{cquote|Under these precedents, a speech host must make one of two showings to mount a First Amendment challenge. It must show that the challenged law either (a) compels the host to speak or (b) restricts the host’s own speech. The Platforms cannot make either showing. And (c) the Platforms’ counterarguments are unpersuasive.<ref>Slip op. p. 27.</ref>}}

{{cquote|Under these precedents, a speech host must make one of two showings to mount a First Amendment challenge. It must show that the challenged law either (a) compels the host to speak or (b) restricts the host’s own speech. The Platforms cannot make either showing. And (c) the Platforms’ counterarguments are unpersuasive.<ref>Slip op. p. 27.</ref>}}