| Line 61: |
Line 61: |
| | | | |
| | ====Genetic fallacy==== | | ====Genetic fallacy==== |
| − | According to a leading logical fallacy website, "The Genetic Fallacy is the most general fallacy of irrelevancy involving the origins or history of an idea. It is fallacious to either endorse or condemn an idea based on its past—rather than on its present—merits or demerits, unless its past in some way affects its present value. For instance, the origin of evidence can be quite relevant to its evaluation, especially in historical investigations. The origin of testimony—whether first hand, hearsay, or rumor—carries weight in evaluating it.
| + | In general, this is the attempt to aver (that is, assert as true) or reject a theory by citing its origins as either reputable or disreputable. The usual expression of this fallacy is "Consider the source!" Thus it becomes a form either of ''argumentum ab auctoritate'' or of ''argumentum ad hominem'', depending on whether one seeks to verify or disprove the theory by this method. |
| | | | |
| − | In contrast, the value of many scientific ideas can be objectively evaluated by established techniques, so that the origin or history of the idea is irrelevant to its value." [http://www.fallacyfiles.org/genefall.html Genetic Fallacy] on [http://www.fallacyfiles.org/ The Fallacy Files]
| + | When the origin of ''evidence'' or of ''premises'' is relevant to the reliability of the same, then asking a hearer to "consider the source" is valid. Judges in courts of [[law]], for example, routinely reject as unreliable the testimony of any witness who has demonstrably lied about a point that matters in the case at hand. The facts that such a witness is asserting might still be true, but they cannot stand without corroboration from another, more reliable witness. |
| | | | |
| − | Classic examples of the genetic fallacy include the argument that evolution is wrong because Darwin was evil or because Darwin recanted on his death bed (he did not recant, but even if he had, it would still be irrelevant). Another common use of the genetic fallacy in the other direction is to dismiss a young earth creationist argument since the young earth creationist is motivated by his or her interpretation of the Bible.
| + | But when corroboration is established, the origins of a conclusion, however tainted, become irrelevant. |
| | + | |
| | + | As an example, [[Gregor Mendel]] established the genetic theory that remains current today, even though Mendel's experimental technique was badly flawed, and he even stands accused of falsifying key data. But succeeding [[science|scientists]], using accepted methods of verification and statistical assessment, have achieved results consistent with this theory. Thus the theory remains valid even though Mendel's original presentation was fraudulent. Any attempt today to discredit Mendel's theory on account of Mendel's sloppy methods would be an example of a genetic fallacy. |
| | + | |
| | + | ===== Reference related to the genetic fallacy ===== |
| | + | * [http://www.fallacyfiles.org/genefall.html Genetic Fallacy] on [http://www.fallacyfiles.org/ The Fallacy Files] |
| | | | |
| | ====Tautology==== | | ====Tautology==== |