| − | [[File:William Edgar Borah portrait.jpg|thumb|left|200px|Sen. Borah opposed the Bill.]] | + | [[File:William Edgar Borah portrait.jpg|thumb|left|200px|Liberal, progressive Republican Sen. Borah opposed the Bill.]] |
| | At the [[Senate Judiciary Committee]], the Dyer Bill elicited "a chilly reception."<ref name=waldrep,p.76>"African Americans Confront Lynching," p. 76.</ref> Newspapers reported by the end of May 1922 that every U.S. senator, save Shortridge, completely doubted the constitutionality of the bill, which languished for six months and failed to gain the support of Idaho progressive Republican William E. Borah, who remained unconvinced even after an extensive correspondence with NAACP president Moorfield Storey.<ref name=tarbert/> Despite professing sympathy with the anti-lynching movement, Borah insisted that federal legislation violated [[states' rights]].<ref>"Peaceful Revolution," p. 95.</ref> | | At the [[Senate Judiciary Committee]], the Dyer Bill elicited "a chilly reception."<ref name=waldrep,p.76>"African Americans Confront Lynching," p. 76.</ref> Newspapers reported by the end of May 1922 that every U.S. senator, save Shortridge, completely doubted the constitutionality of the bill, which languished for six months and failed to gain the support of Idaho progressive Republican William E. Borah, who remained unconvinced even after an extensive correspondence with NAACP president Moorfield Storey.<ref name=tarbert/> Despite professing sympathy with the anti-lynching movement, Borah insisted that federal legislation violated [[states' rights]].<ref>"Peaceful Revolution," p. 95.</ref> |