Scopes' conviction was overturned on appeal by a technicality: the Tennessee Constitution at that time had a clause that any fine in excess of $50 must be set by a jury, not by the judge. The state's Supreme Court vacated the verdict on that basis, and further ruled that, because Scopes no longer lived in the state, the case was moot. | Scopes' conviction was overturned on appeal by a technicality: the Tennessee Constitution at that time had a clause that any fine in excess of $50 must be set by a jury, not by the judge. The state's Supreme Court vacated the verdict on that basis, and further ruled that, because Scopes no longer lived in the state, the case was moot. |