Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
128 bytes removed ,  14:31, July 11, 2007
Line 13: Line 13:     
== Linguistic evidence ==
 
== Linguistic evidence ==
−
Some Christians<ref name="christiananswers"/> cite 18th and 19th century observations on the new field of comparative historical linguistics to support their claims that linguists believe all languages originated in a single language spoken in ancient Mesopotamia. Modern linguists now trace many language families to reconstructed languages spoken before or concurrently with the earliest known human civilizations<ref name="mcwhorter">John McWhorter. The Power of Babel.</ref> and most mainstream linguists are skeptical about attempts to reconstruct the mother languages of languages for which there is no direct evidence<ref name="mcwhorter"/><ref>[http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003036.html Language Log.]</ref>.  
+
Some Christian sources<ref name="christiananswers"/> cite 18th and 19th century observations from the field of comparative historical linguistics showing belief that all languages originated in a single language spoken in ancient Mesopotamia. Some modern linguists now trace a number of language families to languages believed to be reconstructed at the time of the earliest known human civilizations or possibly before.<ref name="mcwhorter">John McWhorter. The Power of Babel.</ref> The Tower of Babel would have predated the earliest known human civilizations as well.  Linguists today are aware it is difficult to reconstruct the mother language for which there is no direct evidence<ref name="mcwhorter"/><ref>[http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/003036.html Language Log.]</ref>.  
   −
To support the Biblical account, the [[Creation Museum]] in Kentucky makes a different claim:  
+
To support the Biblical account, the [[Creation Museum]] in Kentucky reports the following:  
 
<blockquote>The Bible claims that God created a number of human languages at the Tower of Babel "according to their families". Nineteenth-century linguists argued that languages evolved slowly, one by one. Today, linguists recognize languages fall into distinct "families" of recent origin.<ref name="langlog2">[http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/004667.html#more Language Log.]</ref></blockquote>
 
<blockquote>The Bible claims that God created a number of human languages at the Tower of Babel "according to their families". Nineteenth-century linguists argued that languages evolved slowly, one by one. Today, linguists recognize languages fall into distinct "families" of recent origin.<ref name="langlog2">[http://itre.cis.upenn.edu/~myl/languagelog/archives/004667.html#more Language Log.]</ref></blockquote>
−
Few modern linguists would accept that these families' "recent" origin is evidence that they appeared suddenly or all at once, but that the limit on reconstructions is an inherent failing of the comparative method<ref name="langlog2"/>. Since the 1950s, many branches of linguistics have been dominated by the hypothesis that human language has a partially biological origin <ref name="mcwhorter"/><ref>Steven Pinker. The Language Instinct.</ref><ref>Ronald Wardaugh. Investigating Language: Central Problems in Linguistics.</ref><ref>Frederick J. Newmeyer. Linguistic Theory in America.</ref>. If this hypothesis is correct, then the original language (or languages) may have been spoken over 150,000 years before the present.
      +
Since the 1950s in the field of linguistics based upon an evolutionary worldview, there has been a belief that human language has a partially biological origin <ref name="mcwhorter"/><ref>Steven Pinker. The Language Instinct.</ref><ref>Ronald Wardaugh. Investigating Language: Central Problems in Linguistics.</ref><ref>Frederick J. Newmeyer. Linguistic Theory in America.</ref>. If this hypothesis is correct, from the evolutionary perspective, then the original language (or languages) would may have been spoken about 150,000 years ago.
    
== References ==
 
== References ==
nsTeam1RO, nsTeam1RW, nsTeam1_talkRO, nsTeam1_talkRW
13,818

edits

Navigation menu