38
edits
Changes
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Line 475:
Line 475: + +
→Flanders role in Senate censure: Interested reply.
:Norwich, your reliance on Flanders' own autobiography of the events surrounding Senator McCarthy is not set upon a sufficient factual basis. While the info you dislike is attributed to an appropriate primary source, namely the Congressional Record and the secondary sources of the Heritage Foundation [http://www.heritage.org/Research/GovernmentReform/IA5.cfm] and the recent book by Stanton Evans (pages 586-588). I disagree with your changes and challenge them with the aforementioned NPOV sources. [[User:Scorpio|Scorpio]] 22:59, 22 December 2007 (EST)
:Norwich, your reliance on Flanders' own autobiography of the events surrounding Senator McCarthy is not set upon a sufficient factual basis. While the info you dislike is attributed to an appropriate primary source, namely the Congressional Record and the secondary sources of the Heritage Foundation [http://www.heritage.org/Research/GovernmentReform/IA5.cfm] and the recent book by Stanton Evans (pages 586-588). I disagree with your changes and challenge them with the aforementioned NPOV sources. [[User:Scorpio|Scorpio]] 22:59, 22 December 2007 (EST)
::Dear Scorpio, Thank you for your interest in this phase of history surrounding the McCarthy era. I'm unclear as to what aspects of the passage you are uncomfortable with. My concern with the previous text was the absence of sources and their citations. As to material that you cite as the basis of your concern, the Heritage Foundation document does not appear to contradict the wording of the subsection. I don't have access to the Stanton Evans book that you cite (or even know what the title is), but I'm certainly interested to learn the title and know what it says. Perhaps you could post a proposed change of the subsection with proper citations here. Sincerely,--[[User:Norwich|Norwich]] 11:17, 22 January 2008 (EST)
==Book by [[M. Stanton Evans]]==
==Book by [[M. Stanton Evans]]==