Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
575 bytes added ,  21:14, January 24, 2008
no edit summary
Line 7: Line 7:  
I'm disappointed that Supersize Me was included on the list, and would like to know what specific aspects of the documentary contained "junk science".
 
I'm disappointed that Supersize Me was included on the list, and would like to know what specific aspects of the documentary contained "junk science".
   −
For that matter, this article would have a lot more credibility if specific examples of the sue of "junk science" were provided, along with supporting citations, for each of the documentaries in the list.  As it reads right now, this more closely resembles name-calling than an academic-quality categorizing of these documentaries under the definition provided.  Articles like these have to be improved and objectively supported if Conservapedia is going to have any credibility.
+
For that matter, this article would have a lot more credibility if specific examples of the sue of "junk science" were provided, along with supporting citations, for each of the documentaries in the list.  As it reads right now, this more closely resembles name-calling than an academic-quality categorizing of these documentaries under the definition provided.  Articles like these have to be improved and objectively supported if Conservapedia is going to have any credibility. Comment added by [[User:DinsdaleP]]
    
:Agreeing with the anon above me. I'd also like to know how "junk science" even applies to Outfoxed. [[User:Barikada|Barikada]] 15:52, 24 January 2008 (EST)
 
:Agreeing with the anon above me. I'd also like to know how "junk science" even applies to Outfoxed. [[User:Barikada|Barikada]] 15:52, 24 January 2008 (EST)
 +
 +
Super Size Me is, in my opinion, bad science because it portrays a ridiculous scenario. I know McDonalds food is unhealthy, but who actually eats every meal there? Virtually no-one. The author also went from plenty of exercise to not much. That's bound to cause a massive shock to the system in itself. He wasn't just eating bad food; he was eating far too much and any half-sensible person could be a lot less unhealthy by eating a lot less food (primarily buying it from McDonalds).[[User:Barclay|Barclay]] 16:14, 24 January 2008 (EST)
148

edits

Navigation menu