Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
1 byte added ,  22:10, February 26, 2008
m
Line 85: Line 85:  
::::::::: I never said the abortionists took the [[Hippocratic Oath]].  You don't seem willing to retract your false claim that I did, and you seem insistent on confusing people about what the [[Hippocratic Oath]] says about abortion.  It prohibits it.  We can continue this conversation when you let us know for comparison purposes how many psychiatrists were murdered in the last decade, which curiously you seem much less interested in.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 14:06, 24 February 2008 (EST)
 
::::::::: I never said the abortionists took the [[Hippocratic Oath]].  You don't seem willing to retract your false claim that I did, and you seem insistent on confusing people about what the [[Hippocratic Oath]] says about abortion.  It prohibits it.  We can continue this conversation when you let us know for comparison purposes how many psychiatrists were murdered in the last decade, which curiously you seem much less interested in.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 14:06, 24 February 2008 (EST)
   −
:::::::::: 1. The Hippocratic Oath point was dealt with in HMayo's previous post.  Also I noticed that you went and changed the definition of Hippocratic oath part way through this discussion.  Interesting.  The article used to say that fewer than 10% of modern '''Hippocratic oaths''' prohibit abortion.  That is to say over 90% contain no such prohibition.  Even after you altered the article it still says: "...many medical schools now drop the prohibition on abortion and euthanasia from "modernized" versions of the Oath".  I assume you made that change so that you could claim that the ''real'' Hippocratic oath did contain a prohibition and these modern medical schools are not using the genuine article.  Some might regard that as deceitful.
+
:::::::::: 1. The Hippocratic Oath point was dealt with in HMayo's previous post.  Also, I noticed that you went and changed the definition of Hippocratic oath part way through this discussion.  Interesting.  The article used to say that fewer than 10% of modern '''Hippocratic oaths''' prohibit abortion.  That is to say over 90% contain no such prohibition.  Even after you altered the article it still says: "...many medical schools now drop the prohibition on abortion and euthanasia from "modernized" versions of the Oath".  I assume you made that change so that you could claim that the ''real'' Hippocratic oath did contain a prohibition and these modern medical schools are not using the genuine article.  Some might regard that as deceitful.
 
:::::::::: 2. I am happy to inform you that no psychiatrists have been murdered in the last ten years for being psychiatrists.  I find it curious that you say that it is curious that HMayo is less interested in psychiatrists.  Perhaps he was trying to write an article about abortionists, not psychiatrists.  --[[User:GDewey|GDewey]] 17:33, 24 February 2008 (EST)
 
:::::::::: 2. I am happy to inform you that no psychiatrists have been murdered in the last ten years for being psychiatrists.  I find it curious that you say that it is curious that HMayo is less interested in psychiatrists.  Perhaps he was trying to write an article about abortionists, not psychiatrists.  --[[User:GDewey|GDewey]] 17:33, 24 February 2008 (EST)
138

edits

Navigation menu