Changes

::::Actually, Minnie Riperton had two children;  Anastacia was the child of an entertainer and an actress; Soraya's mother herself had breast cancer (a cancer known to be strongly hereditary); Aisha Bicknell, daugther of an actress; Ann Jillian had a son; Amanda Mealing has two sons;  Kylie Minogue is the daughter of an entertainer;  Kate Jackson has a son;  Jill Eikenberry has two children; Cynhtia Nixon has two children;  Edie Falco is the daughter of an actress; Melissa Etheridge is gay;  Julie Ege has two daughters; Shirley Temple had three children:  Olivia Newton-John has a daughter; Sheryl Crow is the daughter of musicians.

::::Actually, Minnie Riperton had two children;  Anastacia was the child of an entertainer and an actress; Soraya's mother herself had breast cancer (a cancer known to be strongly hereditary); Aisha Bicknell, daugther of an actress; Ann Jillian had a son; Amanda Mealing has two sons;  Kylie Minogue is the daughter of an entertainer;  Kate Jackson has a son;  Jill Eikenberry has two children; Cynhtia Nixon has two children;  Edie Falco is the daughter of an actress; Melissa Etheridge is gay;  Julie Ege has two daughters; Shirley Temple had three children:  Olivia Newton-John has a daughter; Sheryl Crow is the daughter of musicians.

It seems none of these individuals fit the thesis that is proposed here, and this 'mystery' seems like it doesn't exist, unless some better examples that fir the theory can be found.  I vote for deletion unless the argument can be made in some sensible way that is not "because someone says it is so".  [[User:GaryK|GaryK]] 16:22, 9 May 2008 (EDT)

::::It seems none of these individuals fit the thesis that is proposed here, and this 'mystery' seems like it doesn't exist, unless some better examples that fir the theory can be found.  I vote for deletion unless the argument can be made in some sensible way that is not "because someone says it is so".  [[User:GaryK|GaryK]] 16:22, 9 May 2008 (EDT)

 

:::::Re. Margery Campbell's theory, I'm afraid that for your theory to be valid, the women listed here would have to be childless, which is not true in most of the cases, as I've pointed out above.  In fact, the cases listed in this article could not seem to have ''less'' relevance to such a theory, and without a shadow of a doubt, the case of Soraya needs to be removed, as in her case, it was clearly hereditary.  So what is the proposed theory that is so obvious?  [[User:GaryK|GaryK]] 17:50, 9 May 2008 (EDT)