| | I have reverted this edit because, with respect to HelpJazz senior I believe the advice contained is unsuitable for teenagers. "Be good, but if you can't be good, be safe" in essence condones misbehaviour; it is saying, "Make sure you don't get caught out". Instead of urging the recipient to behave properly and decently, it in effect says "I know I have to tell you to be good for form's sake, but you and I know that you are going to do drink/drugs/sex, so be careful and don't get busted/pregnant/her pregnant". It is recommending the fallacious belief in actions without consequences. Proper Conservative advice to a teen going to college would be ''Be good, resist temptation, admit your mistakes and learn from them''. [[User:Bugler|Bugler]] 03:43, 10 September 2008 (EDT) | | I have reverted this edit because, with respect to HelpJazz senior I believe the advice contained is unsuitable for teenagers. "Be good, but if you can't be good, be safe" in essence condones misbehaviour; it is saying, "Make sure you don't get caught out". Instead of urging the recipient to behave properly and decently, it in effect says "I know I have to tell you to be good for form's sake, but you and I know that you are going to do drink/drugs/sex, so be careful and don't get busted/pregnant/her pregnant". It is recommending the fallacious belief in actions without consequences. Proper Conservative advice to a teen going to college would be ''Be good, resist temptation, admit your mistakes and learn from them''. [[User:Bugler|Bugler]] 03:43, 10 September 2008 (EDT) |
| | + | :That's certainly ''an'' interpretation, but it's unfair and overly simplistic to say it's the only one. He's not saying "make sure you don't get caught," nor does the advice undercut the "be good" message. Your own suggestion acknowledges the possibility of mistakes that you must learn from. Why not give advice that not only acknowledges that you might fail to be good (despite forthright intentions) but gives secondary advice ("be safe")? Otherwise, you've given NO useful advice to the person who's already mired in an unfortunate position. [[User:Aziraphale|Aziraphale]] 15:34, 10 September 2008 (EDT) |