| | :That's certainly ''an'' interpretation, but it's unfair and overly simplistic to say it's the only one. He's not saying "make sure you don't get caught," nor does the advice undercut the "be good" message. Your own suggestion acknowledges the possibility of mistakes that you must learn from. Why not give advice that not only acknowledges that you might fail to be good (despite forthright intentions) but gives secondary advice ("be safe")? Otherwise, you've given NO useful advice to the person who's already mired in an unfortunate position. [[User:Aziraphale|Aziraphale]] 15:34, 10 September 200good and decent 8 (EDT) | | :That's certainly ''an'' interpretation, but it's unfair and overly simplistic to say it's the only one. He's not saying "make sure you don't get caught," nor does the advice undercut the "be good" message. Your own suggestion acknowledges the possibility of mistakes that you must learn from. Why not give advice that not only acknowledges that you might fail to be good (despite forthright intentions) but gives secondary advice ("be safe")? Otherwise, you've given NO useful advice to the person who's already mired in an unfortunate position. [[User:Aziraphale|Aziraphale]] 15:34, 10 September 200good and decent 8 (EDT) |
| | ::Aziraphale, you make good points which reflect your world outlook. Maybe I am more cynical, but I interpret 'be careful' not in the sense of 'be careful - don't fall under buses, don't cut yourself on sharp knives, don't play with gasoline' but more as 'be careful, be as bad as you like but use ways to escape the consequences of your sin'. It is a smeesge that, to me says: 'don't be chaste; but remember to use contraception' - a message that has appalling moral implications, and, given the failure of contraceptives to control the spread of deadly STDs, serious physical ones as well. [[User:Bugler|Bugler]] 15:41, 10 September 2008 (EDT) | | ::Aziraphale, you make good points which reflect your world outlook. Maybe I am more cynical, but I interpret 'be careful' not in the sense of 'be careful - don't fall under buses, don't cut yourself on sharp knives, don't play with gasoline' but more as 'be careful, be as bad as you like but use ways to escape the consequences of your sin'. It is a smeesge that, to me says: 'don't be chaste; but remember to use contraception' - a message that has appalling moral implications, and, given the failure of contraceptives to control the spread of deadly STDs, serious physical ones as well. [[User:Bugler|Bugler]] 15:41, 10 September 2008 (EDT) |
| | + | :::It sounds like good advice to me. Nobody goes through life without sinning at all. Adolescence & early adulthood is when people are often most tempted, & sometimes they do give in to temptation, despite good intentions. If they do, there will be consequences, but they can still avoid the kind of situations which could ruin the rest of their lives. [[User:Sideways|Sideways]] 15:47, 10 September 2008 (EDT) |