| Line 23: |
Line 23: |
| | Carbon dating, like other [[radiometric dating]] methods, requires certain assumptions that cannot be scientifically proved. | | Carbon dating, like other [[radiometric dating]] methods, requires certain assumptions that cannot be scientifically proved. |
| | These include the starting conditions, the constancy of the rate of decay, and that no material has left or entered the sample. | | These include the starting conditions, the constancy of the rate of decay, and that no material has left or entered the sample. |
| | + | |
| | + | === Calibration === |
| | | | |
| | Unlike other radiometric dating techniques where it is not possible to [[calibration|calibrate]] the method against historically-known dates, limited calibration is possible for carbon dating. | | Unlike other radiometric dating techniques where it is not possible to [[calibration|calibrate]] the method against historically-known dates, limited calibration is possible for carbon dating. |
| Line 28: |
Line 30: |
| | Despite this, however, caution is still necessary in accepting dates derived from carbon dating. | | Despite this, however, caution is still necessary in accepting dates derived from carbon dating. |
| | | | |
| − | First, it had not been proven scientifically whether the rate of decay of <SUP>14</SUP>C has remained constant over hundreds or thousands of years.{{Fact}} Some scientists have suggested, based on experimental observations, that the laws of physics do change over time.<ref>"The idea that nature's laws change over time was proposed in the 1930s by one of the titans in the history of physics, [[Paul Dirac]] of England. According to Dirac's large numbers hypothesis, the force of gravity changed over time." See Keay Davidson, "Recent study forces scientists to rethink basic law of physics," San Francisco ''Chronicle''[http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?file=/chronicle/archive/2005/05/09/MNG5LCLEU41.DTL]</ref> The "change" discussed here - in a study that is still very controversial - occurred over billions of years, though, and not in the near enough future to have had an effect on the utility of carbon dating (since carbon dating is only useful to date life within the past 50,000 years, only a change within 50,000 years would affect the dating method).
| + | Claims have been made of the method being calibrated back to 10,000 years using [[dendrochronology]],<ref name="TH" /> however these older dates derived via dendrochronology have themselves been derived by using carbon dating<ref>Batten, Don, [http://creationontheweb.com/content/view/2441 Tree ring dating (dendrochronology)] (Creation Ministries International).</ref>, making this circular reasoning. |
| | + | |
| | + | === Variable intake === |
| | + | |
| | + | Not all living things do have <sup>14</sup>C:<sup>12</sup>C ratios the same as the atmosphere. |
| | + | {{QuoteBox|...various plants have differing abilities to exclude significant proportions of the C-14 in their intake. This varies with environmental conditions as well. The varying rates at which C-14 is excluded in plants also means that the apparent age of a living animal may be affected by an animal's diet. An animal that ingested plants with relatively low C-14 proportions would be dated older than their true age."<ref>Nondestructive Testing (NDT) Resource Center, [http://www.ndt-ed.org/EducationResources/CommunityCollege/Radiography/Physics/carbondating.htm Carbon-14 Dating"]</ref>}} |
| | + | |
| | + | === Atmospheric variability === |
| | + | |
| | + | The method relies on the assumption that we know how much <sup>14</sup>C is in the atmosphere, but this has been known to change. |
| | + | Nuclear testing since the 1950s has resulted in a large increase in the amount of <sup>14</sup>C in the atmosphere, but because the levels have been measured since the 1950s, calculations can be adjusted for these changing levels, meaning that dating of recent samples is possible.<ref name="K12">Higham, Thomas? [http://www.c14dating.com/k12.html K-12] Radiocarbon web-info.</ref> |
| | | | |
| − | Second, "various plants have differing abilities to exclude significant proportions of the C-14 in their intake. This varies with environmental conditions as well. The varying rates at which <SUP>14</SUP>C is excluded in plants also means that the apparent age of a living animal may be affected by an animal's diet. An animal that ingested plants with relatively low <SUP>14</SUP>C proportions would be dated older than their true age."<ref>Nondestructive Testing (NDT) Resource Center, "Uncertainty in Carbon Dating"[http://www.ndt-ed.org/EducationResources/CommunityCollege/Radiography/Physics/carbondating.htm]</ref>
| + | However, atmospheric levels are also known to have changed since the start of the [[industrial revolution]], making dating items from this period more difficult.<ref name="K12" /> |
| | | | |
| − | Carbon dating cannot give accurate numbers if the sample is younger than 150 years or older than 50,000 years. The inaccuracy for material younger than 150 years is ascribed to changes in the ratio of <SUP>14</SUP>C to <SUP>12</SUP>C in the atmosphere.<ref>http://www.talkorigins.org/indexcc/CD/CD011.html</ref>
| + | Dating laboratories do not make any allowance for the change in atmospheric levels that would have occurred as a result of [[Great Flood|Noah's Flood]]. |
| | + | This means that radio-carbon dates cannot be used to prove that the Flood did not occur, because it ''assumes'' that it did not occur.<ref>Batten, Don, (Ed.) [http://www.creationontheweb.com/images/pdfs/cabook/chapter4.pdf What about carbon dating?] Chapter 4 of the ''Creation Answers Book''.</ref> |
| | | | |
| | ==See also== | | ==See also== |