Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 481: Line 481:     
::: Someone is missing the the point about [[my Muslim faith]], which omits the telling phrase: "Muslim faith."  No Christian would use that specific phrase so casually in reference to himself.  How about someone saying "Allah the Creator"?!  Christians don't use the phrase.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 10:10, 18 November 2008 (EST)
 
::: Someone is missing the the point about [[my Muslim faith]], which omits the telling phrase: "Muslim faith."  No Christian would use that specific phrase so casually in reference to himself.  How about someone saying "Allah the Creator"?!  Christians don't use the phrase.--[[User:Aschlafly|Aschlafly]] 10:10, 18 November 2008 (EST)
 +
 +
== Falsifiability & "My Muslim Faith" ==
 +
 +
Aschlafly, Ed Poor, etc. -
 +
 +
Is there any piece of evidence that, assuming it existed, would convince you that Barack Obama is NOT a Muslim? You've now admitted there's a chance he's not a Muslim, so what piece of evidence would convince you that he's not? As it stands, your argument seems unfalsifiable, and ridiculously conspiratorial: everytime someone offers evidence that Obama's not a Muslim, you just reply with, "oooh, he's a tricky one! He must have worked to cover that up!" That's not a respectable, logical argument: it's an inability to recognize fact when it's put before your eyes. What piece of evidence could convince you of that, if any?
 +
 +
Further, if I go through the George W. Bush talk page I bet I'll find a million examples of you apologizing for Bush's rhetorical missteps, and arguing that when he says something incorrectly, it doesn't mean he's stupid. Why, then, are you not willing to take Obama's slip of the tongue as the same thing - unconscious error, not indicative of any deeper meaning?
 +
 +
The fact is, you have no principled basis for the distinction. Nor are you going to accept any evidence that Obama's a Christian. You're just clinging to a pet theory when even your own administrative staff tells you you're wrong.-[[User:KiraN|KiraN]] 10:26, 18 November 2008 (EST)
13

edits

Navigation menu