Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
no edit summary
Line 20: Line 20:  
*[continued]"and human rights"
 
*[continued]"and human rights"
 
The first one should be easy enough, but it still wouldn't hurt to either be more specific or to point at a source. But the last two claims made me go "Wha-?" because they pretty much come out of nowhere (and then again leave into nowhere). I figure you're a smart guy and based those claims on good sources, so this is just a request to include them in the interest of the reader. Right now, the intro paragraph sounds a lot like an abstract or summary without the rest of the undoubtedly wow-ing article: It's concise and certainly gets a point across, but people can't help but feel that they're missing something. And since the points touched here aren't really picked up in the article, they're left wanting. --[[User:Jenkins|Jenkins]] 14:03, 6 October 2007 (EDT)
 
The first one should be easy enough, but it still wouldn't hurt to either be more specific or to point at a source. But the last two claims made me go "Wha-?" because they pretty much come out of nowhere (and then again leave into nowhere). I figure you're a smart guy and based those claims on good sources, so this is just a request to include them in the interest of the reader. Right now, the intro paragraph sounds a lot like an abstract or summary without the rest of the undoubtedly wow-ing article: It's concise and certainly gets a point across, but people can't help but feel that they're missing something. And since the points touched here aren't really picked up in the article, they're left wanting. --[[User:Jenkins|Jenkins]] 14:03, 6 October 2007 (EDT)
 +
 +
== Intro Paragraph & Article Title ==
 +
This page claims there are many 'Socialist Environmental Disasters' and yet, it cites only one example. Furthermore, 'Socialism' did not cause Chernobyll, and the title 'Socialist Environmental Disasters' indicates 'Socialism' is to blame. Both these factors make this page meaningless. A more appropriate title would be 'Environmental Disasters That Occured In Socialist Countries'. Though, even this would be inaccurate, as only one example is given.

Navigation menu