Changes

Jump to navigation Jump to search
1,183 bytes added ,  19:58, December 2, 2008
psychosomatic improvements
Line 12: Line 12:  
:::(EC with the Dr.)I would call those direct physical effects. The smell of coffee and the ringing of the bell have direct effects on the brain of the people who hear them. Placebos do not have direct effects on the brains of the people who take them. '''Knowing''' or '''believing''' that they are taking a treatment has an effect. Again, the placebo itself does not.
 
:::(EC with the Dr.)I would call those direct physical effects. The smell of coffee and the ringing of the bell have direct effects on the brain of the people who hear them. Placebos do not have direct effects on the brains of the people who take them. '''Knowing''' or '''believing''' that they are taking a treatment has an effect. Again, the placebo itself does not.
 
:::Being physically or chemically inert is part of the '''meaning''' of 'placebo'. If you have philosophical questions about what this means in light of the mind/body debate, that's great. But the article should still be clear about what a placebo is. [[User:DavidJohnson|DavidJohnson]] 14:34, 2 December 2008 (EST)
 
:::Being physically or chemically inert is part of the '''meaning''' of 'placebo'. If you have philosophical questions about what this means in light of the mind/body debate, that's great. But the article should still be clear about what a placebo is. [[User:DavidJohnson|DavidJohnson]] 14:34, 2 December 2008 (EST)
 +
 +
:::(ECx2) Ed as you illustrated above there is a psychological component to how we are able to control our own bodies. That's really how a lot of these liberal new-age talking or touching therapies work (also a good old-fashioned mom's "let me kiss it better"). Because people often feel better fom getting personal attention rather than being palmed of with a couple of apsirin. I guess it's because we all need to be loved and I suspect this is why Christians can withstand greater apparent suffering because they know they are loved by God and Jesus. Placebos tend to work well for things like pain control but are generally ineffective against serious infectious diseases like polio or tetanus, however they can affect how a patient perceives the disease so when testing the efficacy of a new drug placebos are used to establish a baseline against which to measure the effectiveness of the drug. Interestingly when people are told that the placebo is more expensive (obviously they don't know it's a placebo) then it is found to have an even greater effect. Of course, Hollywood stars require incredibly expensive placebos! [[User:BrianCo|BrianCo]] 14:58, 2 December 2008 (EST)
nsTeam1RO, nsTeam1RW, nsTeam1_talkRO, nsTeam1_talkRW
6,302

edits

Navigation menu